Location: New Cumberland
Top Restaurants in New Cumberland
Top Things to do in New Cumberland
Top 10 American food in New Cumberland, Pennsylvania, United States
Reviews on American food in New Cumberland, Pennsylvania, United States. New Cumberland is a borough in easternmost Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, United States. New Cumberland was incorporated on March 21, 1831. The population was 7,277 at the 2010 census. The borough is noted for its historic downtown which includes landmarks like the historic West Shore Theater and the yearly Apple Festival, which gathers hundreds of vendors and thousands of visitors.
Things to do in New Cumberland
10. Appalachian Brewing Company - Harrisburg
Overall Ratings
4 based on 311 reviews
Our original Appalachian Brewing Company brewpub is located in historic Harrisburg, PA. The impressive three-story brick and heavy timber structure was built circa 1915. The lagering room portion of the brewery dates to 1890. Throughout the brewery, antiq
Reviewed By YanieMC
When you walk in it immediately looks like a giant log cabin. Super cozy, especially in these winter months. I sat at the bar, which had ample seating and was greated by 2 bartenders who let me try a couple samples and i went with the brut ipa 1st followed by the barleywine; both were excellent. I ordered the fire jumper as a turkey burger ams i loved it! They have a chipotle like mayo that has a great kick (you guys should make it a ranch too!) to the burger. My 1 complaint is that the chef didnt melt my cheese. It was a very mellow friday night so they have no excuse not to take an extra 10secs for that added touch everyone appreciates. All in all a great place to grab some comfort food and local beer
9. Char's at Tracy Mansion
Overall Ratings
4 based on 304 reviews
Located overlooking the Susquehanna River, Char's offers inventive cuisine, impeccable service with a relaxed, dinner party atmosphere in a grandiose setting.
Reviewed By oldstocks
Really a treat for Hburg. Fun views and great food.Their in-house wine menu is more extensive than online and they have delicious specials. I had the schnitzel and my wife had the coulotte steak. Both were big portions so donât fill up on soups and apps.Perfect for special occasions and a night out.
8. The Millworks
Overall Ratings
4 based on 558 reviews
The Millworks features a brewery, a rooftop biergarten, a local & sustainable restaurant, an outdoor courtyard, and 3 art galleries with 23 artist studios...all under one roof.
Reviewed By yyyzzz111
Typical trendy brewery/"farm to table" place. The view from the bar was nice overlooking the courtyard which unfortunately we could not use due to the rain. The bartenders were friendly. All of the staff were really young and bit unpolished. I bought something rather nice at the gift shop "gallery" and they threw it in the bottom of a bag. The waitress was nice but in a real rush to clear our plates and glasses. The food was ok, the rice in my dish was barely cooked at all. The beer was good, typical craft beer stuff. It was nice to be able to take 6 packs and even individual cans and bottles home. Would have liked more info on the history of the place. There were artists' studios we were told we could visit upstairs, but we felt really awkward walking in on the sole person working up there.
7. The Melting Pot
Overall Ratings
4 based on 250 reviews
Whether with friends, family, or business acquaintances when you fondue together, you stay together. Come Savor Every Moment at The Melting Pot. We offer a completely customization experience of 1, 2, 3, or more courses!
Reviewed By dextersadventures
We celebrated our daughters 23rd Birthday here and am really glad we chose this place.We had the 4 Course Experience. I chose the Classic, my wife the Limitless, and our daughter the steak lovers. There's a lot of choices to choose from in what types of cheese, what type of entre and how you want to cook it. Different salads included in the 4 Course Experience. (I had the California. A bit on the sour side, but I loved it!). Lots of choices for the fondue too. (We had Ying and Yang. It looked and tasted amazing. Different sauces too. Our server Kim was excellent and they even brought out a special plate showing "Happy Birthday" with some rice crispy treats as the cake with a candle. The whole thing was fun and very tasty. So much food, we could barely finish the desert. Be sure to make a reservation in advance.
6. Dodge City Steakhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 348 reviews
Reviewed By MrOcho
This was my first time to this restaurant that was featured on Restaurant Impossible, starring Michael Irvine. It does not have much curb appeal but once inside you forget about the busy road outside. There is a main, but split, dining room that holds about 60 people and another smaller area hidden in the back that seats around 28 by the small U-shaped bar. The décor uses the principle that less is more with its simple yet classy western accents. I did not see the owners (Doug / Debbie) or their son Dougie (Chef) during my visit. Access to and from Route 83 is simple.The menu is simple yet diverse, being only one page. They do sell beer, wine and mixed drinks. The night I dined the back was empty and the front was about 80% occupied. Tables were quickly cleared and reset which is a dying art in a lot of places. I would call this Dodge City a poor manâs upscale steakhouse. There are no cloth napkins or tablecloths and the staff are casually dressed in black logo t-shirts and blue jeans. No there isnât any sawdust on the floor, lol! And yes, Michaelâs highly recommended flooring looked great in the moderately lit restaurant. My meal was served with proper pauses between which I also find rare since all too these days everything is served at once. My order was the Baked French Onion Soup Au Gratin ($5) - Hearty beef broth, onions, crouton, melted Gruyere cheese, the Braised Bison Tacos ($11) - House braised bison, onion, lettuce, tomato, cheese, flour tortilla, tomatillo picante sauce and the Balsamic Marinated Hanger Steak ($20) - Grilled, sliced, smoked tomato & spinach bleu cheese orzo, red wine demi-glace. I was started with two fresh dinner rolls and cinnamon butter. They provide a western steak knife as an accent piece however it does a nice job cutting the rolls!What I Liked:- Fresh rolls are always welcomed- The onion soup was not too salty, and the onions were sweet- The Gruyere cheese worked well, more flavor than mozzarella and not stringy to eat- Thy did not skimp on the shredded bison- The hanger steak (served pre-sliced) was cooked to perfection, very tender and juicy. Overall excellent. My suggestion would be to consider adding peppercorns to the balsamic vinegar marinate.- The risotto worked very well with the bleu cheese ... great favor!- The steak knives (rolls and entrée) were of real man qualityWhat I Did Not Like:- Not a fan of cinnamon butter- The cheese and bread in the onion soup adhered to each other making it impossible to break with a spoon. I had to use a fork to shred pieces off.- The mild flavored bison was overpowered by the bitterness of the dry lettuce. I recommend they add something to the lettuce, reduce the amount of it or use a sweeter lettuce variety.- There was no tomato in the risotto and the spinach was cooked down to nothingMy Prime Minister of Beef rating is 9/10 Mooâs landing this place at the #2 spot of the 17 places I have had beef at in the Carlisle area since February 2019.My overall rating placed this restaurant at #2 of the 81 restaurants I have eaten at in the area since February 2019.
5. Home 231
Overall Ratings
4 based on 431 reviews
Reviewed By woosailor
We just happened to be in Harrisburg on our way to Chadds Ford and stumbled upon Home231. What a pleasant surprise!We decided to try someâsharesâWe had the duck meatballs, General Tso cauliflower, beignets,And an appetizer somewhat like scotch eggs. We were really impressed with the flavors. They were unique and refreshingly different. Very friendly bartender who helped us to make some excellent choices. Would return in a heartbeat and if the entrées are anything like the appetizers should be an excellent place for dinner.
4. Nick's 114 Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 158 reviews
Reviewed By Dean_Amy-2004
Enjoyed a nice dinner here on a week night. The dining area is spacious and separated from the bar area and the game room. Menu was large and diverse enough for anyone to find something theyâd like. Waitress was friendly. Many of the desserts are made in house. Recommend checking it out if youâre in the area.
3. Cafe Fresco Center City
Overall Ratings
4 based on 203 reviews
Urban Café By Day. Metropolitan Gourmet By Night. Located in the heart of restaurant row, Café Fresco Center City continues to be an innovative leader in the Harrisburg dining scene since opening its doors in 2005. The Feng-Shui inspired setting offers co
Reviewed By southford
My date and I went here for dessert and drinks. I ordered the special of the night~ brownie creme brulee and a millionaire's coffee. My date ordered their signature mojito. The creme brulee was orgasmic, I kid you not. With each bite I literally was like oh my goodness this is so good, oohhh ahhhh mmmmmm. Seriously! The drinks were fabulous as well and I do not even like mojitos normally, but this one was out of this world. My only complaint was the waiter we had. Normally, the wait staff is above par and simply exceptional. Ours, was attentive, but to the extreme. He could clearly see we were on a date, we told him as much, and we asked to be given some time alone and we would let him know if he was needed. He had other tables, so I do not understand what his hurry was as we felt like he was pushing constantly for us to leave (we were quiet and keeping to ourselves). His other tables were no where close to being done, so even if we left, he still had at least two other tables still there, which meant he could not leave anyways. He was just kind of annoying and definitely took away from our date being peaceful and romantic. The owner had died very recently, so maybe that was the issue as this has never happened before. Regardless, the food and drinks are fantastic and I would highly recommend both.Hello!We are so happy to hear that you enjoyed your drinks and your meal! Our creme brulee is made in-house daily, and our signature drinks are all hand-crafted by our highly skilled bartenders. We will most certainly share your commendations with them!We are sorry to hear that your server came across as overbearing -- our goal at Café Fresco Center City is to exceed guest expectations in food and in service, but it is never our intention to make a guest feel rushed or annoyed. We sincerely apologize for that. We certainly hope you will consider us on your next date night, and when you call to make your reservation, please let us know you would like an intimate, more private table. We can take extra steps in choosing your table and overseeing your service to ensure we deliver the experience you expect when out for a romantic evening. While we miss Nick dearly, we did want to mention that he sold Café Fresco Center City to us almost five years ago. We were extremely thankful for the opportunity to be mentored by one of the best in the business, and we strive everyday to carry on the legacy he created. Like him, we sincerely appreciate your ongoing support and your five star review! We hope to see you again soon!
2. John's Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 375 reviews
Reviewed By 658joanw
We came to the area to compete in local dog agility trials, so we returned to our hotel late each night. We tried Johns Diner the first evening of our stay because it was conveniently near to our hotel. We liked our food so much that we came back for the next two evenings. We liked the cleanliness, the fast, friendly service and the comfort food. Everything we had was tasty and plentiful. Recommend the stuffed shells, the bleu bacon burger, the shishkebab and the tuna salad melt. Guarantee you won't leave hungry! They also bake their own desserts, which looked fabulous. We were too full with dinner to try them, but other customers said that their desserts were generous and delicious. We would definately go back to Johns Diner if we make another trip to the area.
What to do and see in New Cumberland, United States: The Best Places and Tips
1. The Game Table Cafe
The Game Table Cafe is Central Pennsylvania's first board game cafe. What is a board game cafe? Well first and foremost it is a place to gather with friends and family and connect. In our fast-paced online world many people are seeking an entertainment fo
Reviewed By VictorTheGeek
The Game Table Cafe has been a fantastic addition to the Central PA area. As a cafe, their food and drink selection is wonderful, and the atmosphere is inviting. As a place to play board/tabletop games, the cafe is a true blessing. It's a great place for those who are new to modern board games AND for veteran tabletop gamers.Pros:- They have a nice variety of sandwiches, drinks, and baked goods.- Their soup of the day is always good.- There's a huge board game library that customers can utilize.- The atmosphere is inviting and has great lighting.- During each month, the cafe hosts many different gaming events (role playing, Magic the Gathering, board game demos, etc).Cons:- From time to time, Saturdays are so busy that table space is limited.- Some people may be turned off by the fact that customers have to pay a coverage charge to sit and play games.
New Cumberland Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in New Cumberland
