Location: Key Colony Beach
Top Restaurants in Key Colony Beach
- 1. Key Colony Inn
- 2. Fish Tales Market & Eatery
- 3. King Seafood- Market & Restaurant
- 4. Sparky's Landing Fish and Cocktails
- 5. Island Fish Company
- 6. Marathon Bagel Co.
- 7. Stout's Restaurant
- 8. Havana Jack's Oceanside Restaurant and Bar
- 9. Brutus Restaurant & Seafood Market
- 10. Marathon Grill and Ale House
Top 10 American food in Key Colony Beach, Florida, United States
Reviews on American food in Key Colony Beach, Florida, United States. Key Colony Beach is a municipality in the middle of the Florida Keys, Monroe County, Florida, United States. The population was 788 at the 2000 census. As of 2004, the population estimated by the U.S. Census Bureau was 852.
Things to do in Key Colony Beach
10. Marathon Grill and Ale House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 746 reviews
Great food and fun. We offer full service restaurant and bar. Featuring over 100 craft beers and our very own Ale House cocktails. Daily lunch and dinner specials, game day Sunday plus game night Monday and Thursday. Giving you a late night option for foo
Reviewed By LorraineBeres
My daughter and I had a light dinner of bbq wings, potstickers and key lime blueberry pie. The bbq wings were the best I ever had...meaty with delicious bbq sauce!..potstickers were crispy and tasty...and the key lime blueberry pie was a great ending to the meal! Our attentive and friendly waitress Debbie topped off a great dining experience! We will be back!!
9. Brutus Restaurant & Seafood Market
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1050 reviews
Brutus Restaurant & Seafood Market is a seafood eatery and market that provides fresh seafood to the Marathon, FL area.
Reviewed By Karen P
For a little hole in the wall, this place is just overpriced. Like most Keys restaurants, they do not take in consideration location and local income level. Fish is caught HERE, not imported so why so pricey?Thank you for the review. The reason it is more pricey is the fact that itâs local fish, we like to support local, but the fishermen and women do charge quite a bit more per pound than the fish from food purveyors. Hopefully you can join us in October when we have a locals discounted menu, or we offer a locals discount card as well. Thanks again for the feedback as we are always looking to improve things.
8. Havana Jack's Oceanside Restaurant and Bar
Overall Ratings
3 based on 510 reviews
Reviewed By andybiz
Came here for dinner on our 2nd night in Marathon. Beautiful spot right on the water with beautiful views all around the exterior. We were drawn in by the local dining guide periodical that highlighted many of Marathon's restaurants and specifically had a review of the Tuna Wontons with an almost too perfect looking picture. We were quickly seated upon arrival and had a nice spot near the water. The server came quickly too as the place was not too busy on a Sunday night. She made some recommendations and took our drink order. The mojito and Hemingway daiquiri came out fast with our kid's drinks and were both delicious. We then ordered our meals along with the Tuna Wontons we read about. The Wontons looked like the picture and were equally tasty. Subsequently, our meals came to the table shortly thereafter. My wife had a Caesar salad with some peel and eat shrimp and they were very good, as I sampled some myself. My son had a burger that he enjoyed although it was a little more cooked than he would have liked, but it was still good! My daughter had a pizza with pineapple, but it was also a little more cooked than usual and somewhat burnt at the crust and the cheese didn't ooze when you bit it, but rather broke off. I opted for the fish tacos(Mahi) and they were ok, but again the fish was a bit overcooked, dry, and a bit smallish in size. There were (3) tacos that came with a side and the plate overall was large and the fillings were good. My recommendation would be to maybe reduce the dish to 2 tacos and put more fish in the taco, but I'm not a chef or restauranteur. Overall, we had a good experience, the location was great, and the service was great, but it seemed that some of the food items were overcooked which provided a bit of a letdown. Thank you for your great review! We are so happy you enjoyed our little piece of paradise! We will speak with the chef about the things in reference to the food that you pointed out. We hope you will come visit us again in the future!
7. Stout's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 242 reviews
Reviewed By Yorksgolfer
Friendly service, good choice and tasty food. I'd particularly recommend the cinnamon pancakes. Be warned - you need to be hungry when you go, cos they'll fill you up!
6. Marathon Bagel Co.
Overall Ratings
4 based on 153 reviews
The Florida Keys only genuine Bagel store. Breakfast and Lunch available. Low Carb options available. Non GMO. New York Style bagels with a Keys attitude. We are open 6 days a week. 6:30am-2:00pm. Closed Monday
Reviewed By saintmar10
Delicious poppy seed bagel I had for breakfast with a schmeer of cream cheese! Small cozy Jersey/NY kinda place owned by a New Jersey couple. Good selection of bagels that move quickly. Judge selection of sandwiches both bagel and paninni plus a variety of omelets. Iâll be back!
5. Island Fish Company
Overall Ratings
4 based on 3450 reviews
Reviewed By misspatrick1977
We stopped by on a rainy Monday. Sat at the bar and the bartender quickly took our order. We split the conch fritters which are AMAZING. Service was good and the bathrooms are IMMACULATE. BUT MY HUGE PROBLEM IS SMOKING INSIDE. I understand part of the restaurant is open but I thought smoking inside was a thing of the past Yes I sat at the bar which isn't far from the tables that children sat at.
What to do and see in Key Colony Beach, United States: The Best Places and Tips
4. Sparky's Landing Fish and Cocktails
Overall Ratings
4 based on 2450 reviews
Reviewed By floridasquid
Lunch for five was a good experience.Food was good. A variety of meal types ordered and all were happy.Service friendly and prompt.
Key Colony Beach Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Key Colony Beach
3. King Seafood- Market & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 867 reviews
Stablished since 2010, we offer fresh Local Seafood from our boats and local commercial fisherman. Our customers can order fresh seafood from our Restaurant Menu or from our seafood Market to take home. We are located in the Heart of the Florida Keys. MM-
Reviewed By Sandra T
This is a casual family run restaurant that started out as a seafood market. They still have the market in the front and have added booth seating in the restaurant. Yellow rice and shrimp or fish is great and a large portion. The whole fried snapper is delish. Comes with coleslaw and plantains. Good home made desserts also.
Most Popular Seafood food in Key Colony Beach, Florida, United States
2. Fish Tales Market & Eatery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 783 reviews
Family owned and Operated Seafood/Meat market and Restaurant. We serve the freshest local seafood, burgers, sandwiches, salads and more. Daily Specials; Beer & Wine. Mon.-Fri. 10-8:30; closed Sat. & Sun.
Reviewed By Cosmom54
Fantastic seafood! My husband had the Bavarian fish sandwich he said it was great! I had the Catch of the Day which was Mahi-Mahi. It was awesome! The coleslaw and potato salad was also good. But top it off with some Keylime pie which was out of this world! We will return.
Where to eat Barbecue food in Key Colony Beach: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Key Colony Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 958 reviews
Reviewed By misspatrick1977
We always stop for lunch while visiting KCB. I always get the lunch size seafood italiano. It is amazing and loaded with seafood. Husband got the $10 ribeye...yes $10 off the special menu. It came with veggies and mashed potatoes. We left stuffed with two boxes. Great staff & clean bathrooms.
