Location: Reynoldsburg
Top Restaurants in Reynoldsburg
Reynoldsburg Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Reynoldsburg
Reynoldsburg is a city in Fairfield, Franklin, and Licking counties in the U.S. state of Ohio. It is a suburban community in the Columbus, Ohio metropolitan area. The population was 35,893 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Reynoldsburg
1. Hickory House Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 163 reviews
Reviewed By rjrobbin - Powell, Ohio
We had reservations for 6:30...there was a line waiting..however, we were taken directly to our table...waitress was right there. We chose this restaurant because of the reviews that ribs were the best. The waitress brought our drinks. We ordered onion straws. The bowl came and it was enormous...they were crispy..a dish of barbeque sauce came with them. For dinner, ordered a slab...half a slab would have been more than sufficient. Side salad and fries. The dinners came...the ribs filled the plate. They were tasty, meaty..couldn't have asked for more. The service was prompt and friendly. Considering it was new years eve, I would have thought we would be rushed through dinner. The opposite was true. We enjoyed our meal.
2. La Fogata Grill
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 162 reviews
Reviewed By TravelSmart4u
Margaritas were good. Food was brought very quick. We ordered and finished our meal in 30 minutes. Server was nice and spent time teaching us about his favorite sport that was on tv - futbol.
3. Jolly Pirate Donuts
Overall Ratings
5 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By T W - New Albany, Ohio
Fantastic donuts cooked fresh and delicious. Sure beats donuts you will get at either the grocery store, Tim Hortons or Dunkin. Prices are comparable to those other donut shops, but these are way better. This place is out of the way from where I live, but it was worth the trip. Highly recommended if you are in the area.
4. Tim Hortons
Overall Ratings
4 based on 34 reviews
Reviewed By TripPhotographer52 - Ohio
Actually, I went to the Tim Hortons at 3065 London-Groveport Rd in Grove City, Ohio but it was not listed on the options. I love Tim Hortons' coffee- especially the "coffee mocha"- which is mixed coffee and hot chocolate. I was driving back from Columbus to Cincinnati today after visiting my daughter and son-in-law and grandchildren and needed some caffeine, so I stopped into Tim Hortons in Grove City which is in the same building as Wendy's. I got a large coffee mocha and a donut and some Wendy's french fries which got me perked up to drive the two hours back to Cinci down 71. I have also had Tim Hortons' sandwiches that are very good also. Service was fine.
5. Scali Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 120 reviews
Reviewed By JoD R - Zanesville, Ohio
Every chance we get we go to Scali's, they never disappoint us. Always make reservations if you don't they do now have seating at the bar and kitchen. I suggest asking your server what the specials are upon arrival. Their specials are truly a special and they normally run out. So make sure to get your order in early. We receive their emails weekly that tell you about their specials. It is truly the closest thing to being in Italy.
6. Thai Paradise
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 102 reviews
Thai Paradise was established in 2008 and is inspired by the traditional beauty of Thailand. Our carefully prepared and fresh cuisine complimented by our inviting ambiance has brought in a stream of loyal fans. Our focus on quality and consistency has made us an integral part of the Pickerington community. We look forward to bringing the same spirit to Athens, which opened in October of 2014. Pride is placed on providing outstanding customer service to compliment the presentation of these fresh recipes. Popular house favorites include the Himmapan Chicken, Pad Ka Pow, and Naum Toak. Our variety of Asian cuisine spans from China, Korea, Vietnam, and to all over the different cities of Thailand. We invite you to enjoy your next dining experience with Thai Paradise. Kop Kun!
Reviewed By Mariah H - Lancaster, Ohio
I was back up in the Pickerington area, and found that Thai Paradise had recently moved. The new location seems to have more seating, which is a definite plus. I had a crab rangoon appetizer, which was delicious; this is not your run-of-the-mill cream cheese...MoreThank you for visiting us in our new location! We love being here and serving excellent Thai food
7. 5 Bean Coffee
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 10 reviews
Reviewed By Pouty27 - Dublin, Ireland
I love coffee..and read all the reviews about this place during my business visit in the US and wanted to get a good strong tasty coffee.
Have to say,when you enter the coffee shop, the smell is lovely and staff were nice. However, the girl who served me had really hard time to understand what I wanted: a coffee with full fat whipped cream! She kept asking me if I wanted half and half. Despites me trying to explain and her colleague who fully understood what I wanted, the girl could not understand my request.
Also if you ask for a whipped cream and do not want sugar, make sure to mention it because my cream was full of sugar.. Am not used to it, as most of the time when I asked for cream, it's automatically sugar free.
Coffee was ok-ish but was expected something tastier that would have given a kick..
8. Prost
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 77 reviews
Reviewed By darylkulak - Westerville, Ohio
Wow, the bartenders are so friendly here! I had an amazing time at Prost. It is an eclectic place, welcoming and cozy while also quirky.
I just had drinks but the menu looked great, especially the bruschetta bar. I counted 23 microbrews on tap and a couple of sangria containers.
Prost is not expensive but is what I'd called "super chic." Naomi, the main bartender, keeps things light and fun, involving everyone in conversation.
There was even a selection of surrealistic artwork for sale on one of the walls. There were a number of TVs playing sports. And, thankfully, the wi-fi was lightning fast.
Reynoldsburg is not exactly in my neighborhood, but Prost will be a reason for me to come here over and over!
9. Cracker Barrel
Overall Ratings
4 based on 111 reviews
Reviewed By marthagrodesky - Columbus, Ohio
WOW! We had the best experience here yesterday. Happy waitress, prompt service, refills before glasses empty. Food was fabulous! Portions are quite large and we wasted a lot. We will definitely return and likely split meals or order less. Only caution was for anyone on a low carb, no carb diet. Not many options.
10. City Barbeque Reynoldsburg
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 90 reviews
The idea for City Barbeque was born as an invitation to all the people in the city to enjoy great barbeque- America's food. Our award-winning barbeque is made with only the highest quality meats and served with our signature sauces on the side. Huge smokers are loaded daily to guarantee the very best hickory smoked, juicy, tender meat anywhere. So if an authentic barbeque experience is what you're after, look no further. Small groups of folks like us still believe in honoring quality, generations of tradition and true service. Whether you call it barbecue, Bar-B-Que, BBQ, or barbeque - we've got what you are looking for!
Reviewed By Judy H - Reynoldsburg, Ohio
had bbq ribs and was cooked perfect. Very tender. Highly recommend the bbq ribs and the sweet tea is the best in Reynoldsburg hands down.
