Location: Newberry
Top Restaurants in Newberry
Newberry Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Newberry
Newberry is a village in the U.S. state of Michigan and the county seat of Luce County. Located within McMillan Township at its very southern end, it shares some administrative responsibilities with the surrounding township. The population was 1,519 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Newberry
1. Tahquamenon Falls Brewery & Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 714 reviews
Reviewed By MI_adventure_gal
Every single time I've visited Tahquamenon Falls I have stopped here to eat. The restaurant itself is typical UP decor-but it's done perfectly. The beer is ok, but the whitefish is the best I've ever had. I've brought people here after raving about it for months and they agree with me. It's a must-do while visiting the falls
2. The Scoop
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 27 reviews
Family owned ice cream shop in rural Newberry, Mi since 1998. Wide range of food from ice cream to paninis to nachos. Open April-September
Reviewed By MstqMI - Manistique
My mother & I decided to have a little snack and I was thrilled to see that they still make malts. So many places only make shakes now but I love the malt flavor. I had a chocolate malt and it was great- nice & thick with the malt flavor.
3. North Star Bakery
Overall Ratings
5 based on 5 reviews
Reviewed By Claude F - Bristol, Tennessee
For nearly two decades, this rustic little shop has been producing superior breads. Located off the beaten path, about 15 miles north of Newberry, Michigan, it's well worth the journey. They really know how to make bread. We made the trip, bought two loaves and brought them home. They make great toast and sandwiches and are excellent with just a pat of butter. Each loaf is large, well-packaged and tasty. Happy trails.
4. Timber Charlies
Overall Ratings
4 based on 297 reviews
We specialize in good old fashioned hand cooking. Grinding our choice chuck for burgers, baking our bread fresh,hand cutting only premium certified high end choice to prime black angus steaks and homemade soups and sandwiches are just a few of our offerings. Now offering a variety of fresh meats from our on sight smoker, including Brisket, Boston pork butt, St. Louis style ribs and Applewood smoked baked beans. Now Offering U.S.D.A. Prime Steaks.
Reviewed By sgdoug
Food was great, and fairly priced. Dining area was freezing, property did not have any heat on even though it was just around freezing outside. I'm sure it's just because of the abrupt weather change, but it made for an uncomfortable dining experience. Food however...MoreDoug we will turn up the heat for ya next time! thanks for the shout out.
5. Pine Stump
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 67 reviews
Reviewed By s g - Lansing, Michigan
We have been here several times in the past.We got the pizza because how can you go wrong? The pizza is thin crust but it looked like someone threw the items on without any placement.Too mush crust all around shows a cheap pizza.I dont really enjoy 2" of crust.probably will skip stopping next time and hit deer park.
6. Seder's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 43 reviews
Reviewed By bushwhack - Michigan
Seder's does wood-fired thin crust pizzas one at w time so you might have to wait a bit. And it's worth it. No gimmicky 'flavored' or greasy doughy crusts--just chewy/crispy browned crust with an excellent sauce and honest toppings. Yummy.
7. Pickelman's Pantry & Pub
Overall Ratings
3.5 based on 86 reviews
Family style restaurant featuring breakfast anytime, wraps and specialty sandwiches, smaller portions for Seniors, pasties, lower level Pub Sports Bar, busses welcome, daily specials, pizza, Mexican, variety of desserts and so much more!
Reviewed By shroom_of_doom
Boy if I could give 0 stars this would be the review to do so. After traveling well over 400 miles on my vacation I certainly didn't expect this much disappoint. Of all my past reviews I believe I found the mother of them all worst restaurants my pallette has tried to endure and my patience. Upon walking in it says seat yourself. Ok that was easy. Next comes asking about the beer selection to our waitress.I asked what do you have? The waitress replies " we don't have a beer menu but if you name one I can check if we have it" Ummm ok.. what kinda of dark beers do you have I asked. Waitress replies with 2 dark beers I've never heard of and she also adds we have Sam adams I think is considered a dark.. smh. What type of ipa beer I ask. She replies 51k because it has ipa on the end of it. Oy..
So I ordered the grilled chicken club type combo thing (forgot the menu name) no tomatoes with ranch and fries. My friend ordered spaghetti with a salad. The waitress said to my friend it would be faster for my friend to goto the salad bar and make herself a salad rather then the waitress making it. My friend said the salad bar is more like your grandmother's pantry and the selection was subpar.
Sitting on my thumbs flipping through some trivia cards stashed in some sugar holder dispenser time drags by. 20 minutes goes by after ordering food. Not even 1 update from my waitress. She didn't even acknowledge us as if we were invisible. 30 minutes goes by, my once cold beer is now room temperature warm and I'm at the point of just walking out and paying just for the beer and pop my friend ordered. 47 minutes goes by and the clouds parted and finally we were served. I mean seriously a grilled chicken and spaghetti isn't hard to make. I seriously could've have ordered a steak well done from a steak restaurant, ate it and left in the time It took for us to be plated.
My friends spaghetti was mushy and clumped, mozzarella cheese was just warm, half burnt garlic bread and the diced tomatoes that was their so called spaghetti sauce was literally canned. I instantly tasted that metallic can taste. Spaghetti is supposed to have spaghetti or marinara sauce. This had spaghetti and diced canned tomatoes. That's it! Where is the sauce??? Our waitress had to be called by name from me just to get her attention so she could remove this so called spaghetti off our bill. No way in h3ll am I paying for that slop. If you can't even get something as basic as spaghetti right then one shouldn't even be cooking.
Subpar food, a embarrassing salad bar, poor service staff, way too long of a wait just for 2 sandwiches, ditzy waitress and burned bread. Just horrible. I seriously recommend that you do not goto this restaurant. You have several fast food restaurants and even a pizza restaurant right across the street which would be 5 star cuisine compared to this establishment. Thank god I'm only passing through this town and will never ever return.
8. Joshua James Bar & Grill
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 28 reviews
Cozy little bar with great bar fair and dinner specials. Fresh whitefish every friday. Outside patio and yard game area. Friendly atmosphere with cold beer and good drinks!
Reviewed By BlackCatMN - Wayzata, Minnesota
If you are looking for just a simple burger, fried food and basic beer, this is the place for you. Very limited menu and bar.
9. Wolf Inn
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 15 reviews
.
Reviewed By Phillip N - Chicago, Illinois
If you're looking for a healthy, small plates kind of place, pass this one by. however, if you want great meatloaf, really good and crispy fried chicken, and other comfort food, this is the place for you It fits the UP surroundings perfectly. Great service We loved it.
10. Zellar's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3.5 based on 92 reviews
Reviewed By bittychicken - Bradenton, Florida
I had a great fish dinner at this restaurant. There are several varieties of fresh water fish. I had the perch, and it was so so good!
