Location: Rye Brook
Top Restaurants in Rye Brook
New York, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Rye Brook
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Rye Brook, New York, United States. Rye Brook is a village in Westchester County, New York, United States, within the town of Rye. The population was 9,347 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Rye Brook
10. Capers Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 26 reviews
Cozy and eclectic mediterranean restaurant with outdoor sitting during summer. Our menu revolves around great Italian, Spanish and Greek food with some vegetarian options and plenty of seafood.
Reviewed By Ron T
This was our first visit to Capers. Some friends had gone before and gave it mediocre review - pretty good food with high prices. For us, it was near perfect. We had the Greek salad to start which was OK. The Bronzino and the Skirt Steak were great. Both were well seasoned and cooked perfectly. The chocolate mousse was velvety. Service was very good.
9. T&J Restaurant & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By RockridgeC
For years we frequented T&Js on Westchester Avenue both in the small trattoria and the larger restaurant next door. When they closed we were sad because we spent some wonderful times there with in-laws, children and such.Last week, my wife and I went to a concert at the Capitol and she recommended we try the NEW T&Js now on Pearl Street. I was totally into that.When we arrived and were seated, I recognized some of the servers from the old place and we nodded hello to each other, a comforting sign. Mary, our server set us up quickly with some bread and wine and even agreed to intercede with the kitchen on my behalf as I wanted a dish not on the menu but one they prepare really well and that I love.The food was great, Mary was attentive and helpful even though they were slammed and finally when the owner, Grace came by to say hello, our night was made! We went off to our concert, sort of floating on air thinking, T&J s is back and the world is a wonderful place!If you haven't been here you are missing something special!
8. John's of Arthur Avenue
Reviewed By BobLeblaw
It's a tough game, opening a pizzeria (and Italian restaurant) in the Port Chester area, because there are so many other good ones. Thankfully for all of us, John's brings real competition to the pizza game. They make an awesome pie here, and the owner and his staff are friendly, and happy to see you. Go here. Try their pizza...you'll be back.
7. Marianacci's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 38 reviews
Reviewed By paul1009
Itâs been decades since Iâve been to Marianacciâs.Thereâs no good reason. You move around, try different places, go to the new hot places, develop new favorites.For no particular reason, we decided to go on a Friday night. I figured it would be crowded and made an early reservation.We got there early and were taken to a nice table.The ambiance is charming, dimly lit with quiet background music so you can have a nice conversation.Thanks My wife ordered shrimp cocktail which was fresh and delicious with good sized shrimp.I ordered the stuffed mushrooms, very good.She had linguine with clams, a good size with lots of clams.I had a wonderful unique veal parmigiana. It was unique because unlike a lot of other vealparmigiana this did bot have a thick later of breadcrumbs. I think many places premake it, freeze it then heat it when itâs ordered. The veal was sautéed with mozzarella on top served on a platter with a side of pasta. Sauce was very good but only on the pasta not the veal.Chef made a delicious cheesecake.Service was very professional.Prices are average to low for great Italian food.We will return shortly. It is one of the best Italian restaurants in Westchester.
6. Villa Rustica Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
Reviewed By 848bobm
Suggest reserving a table on a Saturday night. Well prepared food, lots of options, pasta served very hot. Pizza quite tasty! Donât bother with the bread- not worth the effort- very hot, but tasteless.
5. Mediterraneo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 264 reviews
The colors and flavors of the Mediterranean come to life at Mediterraneo, located on the exclusive Greenwich Avenue in the heart of Greenwich, Connecticut. Bathed in the soothing tones of sand and sea, the restaurant features an inviting outdoor terrace a
Reviewed By Ron T
We go a few times a year, usually a drink and snack at the bar. Today it was the pizza. The wood oven gives the crust a light char and the toppings were great. Sitting at the bar, service is always great.
4. T&J Pizza and Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 77 reviews
Reviewed By JDN535
Birthday Sunday afternoon dinner with my wife and two teenage daughters. Late afternoon was not crowded but place was filling up as we finished our dinner. Excellent choices. Shrimp parmigiana and Chicken Siciliana were huge portions and left us full. Excellent penne all a vodka also as well as good specials. Our waitress was friendly and attentive and food came out in a timely manner. This has to be one of the best Italian Restaurants in Westchester County. We will be back and look forward to visit8ng again soon.
Most Popular Pizza food in Rye Brook, New York, United States
3. Fortina
Overall Ratings
4 based on 46 reviews
Reviewed By BobLeblaw
Super casual, with awesome food. They have two giant wood-burning pizza ovens that cranks out awesome pies. They even have an "Original Ray's Pizza" on the menu, and I asked about that, since that claim is hotly debated in NYC, and was told that they were making a joke, since it's such a source of contention in NYC. They put it on the menu as a way to poke fun at the whole thing.
2. Aurora
Overall Ratings
4 based on 128 reviews
Located on Purchase Street in the quaint, seaside town of Rye, New York, Aurora ushers diners into an authentic Italian oasis, where the smell of wood-fired pizzas, rich, homemade pastas, and sumptuous entrees create a mouth-watering welcome. The restaura
Reviewed By TJWolf
A very casual vibe with attentive wait staff. Reviews of loud acoustics are accurate, although attempts at attenuation are evident. Beet salad, burger cooked perfect to medium rare, tiramisu and bread pudding to die for. Donât skip the bread, especially the focaccia. The only miss was the gnocchi, a bit over cooked with overpowering sauce. Will definitely return when in the area.
1. Tarry Lodge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 422 reviews
Reviewed By DoJH
Nice lunch. Had pulpo to start followed by polpetti in fresh tomato sauce with ricotta. Seared sea scallops to follow. Found the olives, brocoli rave and concentrated tomato sauce a tad overwhelming for scallops. Nice wine list. Excellent service. A local staple. Thanks so much for your kind review. We are working on changing the preparation on the scallops. Please feel free to ask for our dinner scallop preparation. It is a much lighter dish with better balance. We really do appreciate your feedback and look forward to seeing you soon. Please make sure you ask for Daniel.
Where to eat American food in Rye Brook: The Best Restaurants and Bars
