Location: Carle Place
Top Restaurants in Carle Place
New York, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Carle Place
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Carle Place, New York, United States. Carle Place is a hamlet and census-designated place (CDP) in the Town of North Hempstead in Nassau County, New York, United States. The CDP's population was 4,981 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Carle Place
10. Maggiano's Little Italy
Overall Ratings
4 based on 134 reviews
Reviewed By ZERO-NONSENSE
Back yet-again for another enjoyable meal at Maggianoâs Garden City in the Roosevelt Field Complex off Old Country Rd in the Garden City area of Long Island NY.... for us, the re-assuring feeling that your profile is on-file complete with your food-allergies / special food-needs / preferences etc ... is so refreshing in not having to continually repeat all that at each re-visit; and, that the chef personally comes out each time to completely review & validate everything, is also a great reassurance. Each time the meal comes-out âtailor-madeâ, you can now set-aside your food-issue-concerns and just enjoy your company & great tasting meal served by such pleasant attentive Gracious Table Servers.Ahhh ... relaxing care-free enjoyable dining st decent prices.HOW SWEET IT ISâ¼ï¸
9. Cassariano
Overall Ratings
4 based on 53 reviews
Reviewed By bendover10
We went to this restaurant based on the good reviews. Our experience was anything but good! We waited quite a while for a waiter. The wine I ordered never came. The caesar salad was just passable and had some unidentifiable "things" the size of a crouton but soft and tasteless. I had cavatelli bolognese which was meat and fat, tasteless. I just ate a little of it. The waiter couldn't understand why I didn't want to take the rest home. He did comp my desert because I didn't eat my main course. My wife had the whole wheat pasta with veggies. She said it was just ok, a lot of pepper. The desert was good. Very noisy, poor service, we won't be back
8. Passione Della Cucina
Overall Ratings
4 based on 166 reviews
Reviewed By 26Joanne1946
We were celebrating my brother-in-laws 80th Birthday at home. We selected his favorite foods from Passione catering menu. Chicken Francase, rigatoni bolognese, eggplant rollatine, meatballs, sausage, chicken fingers, classic Caesar salad, chopped salad, with dressings on side. Garlic knots, and their Italian bread triangles. All 30+ relatives raved about the food. And they delivered, and set up. The cost for all the food was reasonable. My husband and I were very happy.
7. Piccolo's of Mineola
Overall Ratings
4 based on 54 reviews
Reviewed By Montauk123
Six adults had dinner here recently. My son had heard about their ravioli and wanted to try. We were not disappointed. Place is charming with adequate parking. Service was top notch. Portions large and flavorful. Gluten free options. Save room for dessert. Highly recommend.
6. Rialto
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
Reviewed By 999feliceb
Had a great dinner with family last night. Shared a Beet salad, and baked cauliflower oreganata as appetizers since my sister and I are dieting and they were delicious and filling. Main courses included Orrechiette with sausage and broccoli rabe, branzino with shrimp with vegetables (asked for double portion instead of potatoes, along with the special of sea scallops with black risotto and roasted duck left us so full we couldnât eat dessert even though they looked delicious. Dinner wines were also good. Service is impeccable, and it helps to go early as itâs a place to dine and enjoy conversation.
5. Polo Lounge at Westbury Manor
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
After enjoying drinks at the large circular bar in Westbury Manor's Polo Lounge, you will be seated in our intimate Dining Room with softly lit tables where you are ensured a unique dining experience. Relax and savor a glass of imported wine and tantalize
Reviewed By LollysLook
We attended a wedding here. The cocktail hour was very good with a large assortment of choices. The sit down dinner was excellent with one of the best wedding dinners we have ever had.
4. Spuntino Wine Bar & Italian Tapas
Overall Ratings
4 based on 137 reviews
Reviewed By trekker27nyc
So disappointed! Our first visit to the Westbury location was when my family and I was invited here by my cousin in 2018. When we were seated, the chef came over to our table and I realized my cousin knew the chef. The chef recommended some items and we ordered some items. All was absolutely delicious! In January, we returned, for lunch, thinking we would have the same level of quality and service. My wife and I had the BBQ Pork and my son, the Spuntino Burger, along with other items. WE WERE NOT IMPPRESSED! There was hardly any pork on the bun and what was on it, was fat, which we removed. It was not only my BBQ Pork but also, my wifeâs. The side or salad as we were told, was chick peas. Nothing wrong with the chick peas but the quantity looked like it was about 2 table spoons. For $14, one would expect a good quantity. As for my sonâs burger, it was over cooked and dry. Overall, the food appeared to be put together in a hurry with whatever was left over. Visually, it was not impressive nor did it taste like there was some thought put into it. A restaurant should always have consistency in the quality of its food.Hello, we are disappointed to hear about your recent lunch visit with us as it certainly wasnât up to our standards. If youâd please private message us your phone number our general manager would love to reach out!
3. Cafe Formaggio Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 174 reviews
From the intoxicating aroma of plum tomato, basil and rich Italian cheeses, to the smoky goodness of thin crust personal pizzas, Cafe Formaggio offers a meal to please just about everyone. Specialized in Gluten Free cuisine with the most extensive Gluten
Reviewed By billp25
They have an unrelenting devotion to the celiac community. And so, if you have celiac's, add a star. As far as an italian restaurant, they have all the usual fare expected at a neighborhood LI place. Although the food arrives from the kitchen piping hot, the recipes themselves are fairly bland, showing little distinctive flavor. Similarly to the wine list, no hidden italian (or italian american) gems hiding here. And unfortunately, servers are easily distracted by calls from others, and so don't focus on the table at hand. Desserts somewhat disappointed, again, nothing flawed, just nothing exciting. Bathroom was not clean.
2. Cafe Baci
Overall Ratings
4 based on 329 reviews
Reviewed By AmericaOverEasy
I honour Anyone who can eat the entire portion of anything in this place! When I ordered the small version of the 'lunch special eggplant' I thought I'd happily plow thru to completion... instead I've got a 'dogie bag' for the next Breakfast, Lunch and Dinner.... and it was fabulous food. Furrgetaboutit for the starters, and bring an appetite.
Most Popular American food in Carle Place, New York, United States
1. Vincent's Clam Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 414 reviews
Reviewed By bigspyndoc1
Located in Carle Place for 3+ decades, the food is so consistently good with massive portions, it is always busy. Their seafood, pasta and especially their sauce (shipped all over the world) make this the favorite Italian/seafood restaurant for multi-generations. Their sauces (mild-med-hot) are just the best. The hot is too hot for me, but their mild and medium dance on my palate. Started with a beautiful caprese salad and fried zucchini wheels for the table. I had shrimp balls Parmigiana over angel hair with medium sauce, my brother ordered eggplant rollatini. As good as ever! It's my "go-to" whenever I visit L.I.
Where to eat Diner food in Carle Place: The Best Restaurants and Bars
