Location: Big Pine Key
Top Restaurants in Big Pine Key
Most Popular Restaurants in Big Pine Key
Big Pine Key Vacation Rental Big Pine Key and its neighboring islands are some of the most popular vacation destinations for families who want to rent a beachfront house or condo. The climate in this part of Florida is delightful and very similar to the warm and pleasant climates of the Caribbean. The crystal blue waters and the white sandy beaches in Big Pine Key make this an impressive location for your next vacation rental. Things to Do Big Pine Key is a fantastic place to come if you want to get away from all the troubles and stress of day-to-day life. The vacation houses and condos available here are designed for rest and relaxation. The main appeal of Big Pine Key is the tranquil environment and beautiful scenery. There are plenty of outdoor activities that you can enjoy when you’re not in your rental home, such as fishing, walking and biking, and seeking out wildlife. Many people visiting Big Pine Key enjoy getting out into the ocean for excellent snorkeling and diving. Looe Key is located approximately 7 miles off shore and provides the perfect location to see stunning sea life. It is widely regarded as one of the clearest and best reefs for snorkeling and diving in the Keys. Family Fun If you’re visiting Big Pine Key with children, there are numerous wonderful activities that will get them out of the rental home for the day. The Theater of the Sea and the National Key Deer Refuge are great options for the whole family. If you would like to spot some of the many alligators that reside in the area, then you should head to the Blue Hole. Delicious Dining in Big Pine Key If you’re staying in a vacation home in Big Pine Key, you may choose to dine in and enjoy a quiet intimate or pizza with the family. There are many local groceries where you can purchase fresh seafood and produce to prepare a meal in your condo or villa. However, if you do fancy a meal out, you can take a trip to Rob’s Island Grill, The Big Pine Restaurant, or The China Garden. All of these restaurants are local and provide culinary delights. Benefits of Big Pine Key Rentals Unlike a hotel, staying in a Big Pine Key vacation rental provides you with complete privacy and tranquility during your vacation. Enjoy the space and security you can get from your own beautiful rental home.
Things to do in Big Pine Key
1. Bucktooth Rooster Eatery
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 236 reviews
Reviewed By Bruce K
This restaurant is conveniently located right on the Overseas Hwy with ample parking. The staff is friendly and efficient, that's the vibe. There is a nice, medium sized bar with good TV placements. There was a fair amount of take-out business going on each time we visited, probably because the food is so good. The menu is varied, American fare. The restaurant is busy but the staff maintain a nice flow. This was our 'go to' eatery for the 3 days we were out on Big Pine. I don't think you can go wrong at the Bucktooth Rooster. 4 out of 5 just because there's always room for improvement (although I don't have any specific recommendations)
2. Cone Republic
Overall Ratings
5 based on 28 reviews
We had just celebrated our one year anniversary when Hurricane Irma swept through and destroyed my Florida Keys based ice cream business. We are looking to rebuild and reopen as soon as we can. Got to keep the Keys alive! Any donations to our GoFundMe page are much appreciated and will be used to rebuild this local favorite Help spread the word! https://www.gofundme.com/4fxo7lc
Reviewed By ijb123 - Miami, Florida
We randomly stopped on our way to Key West and OMG what a surprise!!! It is authentic homemade ice cream infused with flavor not sugar like most ice creams. Authentic flavors with a local twist. Also incredible home made waffle cones with a cinnamon hint.
Highly highly recommended!!! Must stop!
3. Five Brothers Grocery Two
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 142 reviews
There is one on Sumberland Key also, but we couldn't find it.
Reviewed By Alyssa L
Stopped in on our way to Bahia Honda for some lunch to go. Got two Cuban mix sandwiches, a chicken empanada and a beef empanada, and a guava and cheese pastry. Oh. My. Everything was just divine. And the prices cannot be beat! Stop in here if you love delicious food and friendly service!
4. Square Grouper
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 1 reviews
Innovative fresh local seafood. House Smoked Fish Dip is phenomenal, a definite "must try"!! Our Conch Chowder and our Key Lime Pie are also something you should not miss. We also have a great Square Grouper Fish Sandwich, 16 oz Grilled Ribeye (Certified Angus Beef!), Salads and lots of small plates to share...Flash Fried Conch with ponzu and wasabi. We are open on Mondays from the last week in December thru April! We close every September from the Sunday AFTER Labor Day and reopen on the Thursday BEFORE Columbus Day Weekend.
Reviewed By Tara T
Relaxed environment with exceptional eye for detail. Fresh local seafood daily. Best place for a awesome lunch and/or dinner in all of The Keys. Definitely worth the drive from anywhere.
5. No Name Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1 reviews
Reviewed By Allen21096 - Chicago, Illinois
We were going to Key West and we decided to stop at the No Name Pub and see if they were open after Hurricane Irma. Though there is a lot of damage in the area, it appeared that No Name Pub was quickly repaired of any damage. We ordered the pizza. Though it is not near as good as a Chicago pizza, it is surprisingly good. Check out the dollar bills stapled all over. I know that I have one up there somewhere, since I started coming down to Big Pine Key to dive in about 1990. The service was good and the price was reasonable. We opted to sit inside. One thing that we did not see or find in the area, as we were driving to the pub, were any key deer.
6. Boondocks Grille & Draft House
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 1 reviews
HUMBLE BEGINNINGS FOR THE LARGEST TIKI BAR IN THE FLORIDA KEYS Boondocks opened their doors over 25 years ago as a small ice cream shop. The current kitchen was the entire building. Quickly realizing Ramrod Key was in need of more than just ice cream the original owners expanded the menu to include sandwiches, and later added beer and wine to the mix. It wasn't until 2001 that the real transformation began to take place. Lanny was first to arrive in the Florida Keys and scope out Boondocks. Seeing past the overgrown trees and broken tables he immediately called this father, Larry and long time friend and colleague, John to hop the next flight down and check out their new home. With Lanny's vision, John's restaurant expertise and Larry's backbreaking work ethic, Boondocks Grille and Draft House and Miniature Golf has become one of the most popular destinations on the overseas highway.
Reviewed By rbolton0801 - Savannah, Georgia
We were down in the Keys for Thanksgiving and we weren't quite sure where to eat Thanksgiving dinner at. Some recommended this place. It was fantastic!!! They had just about anything you could possibly think of for the Thanksgiving buffet. Being away from home and family for the holiday wasn't so bad after all!!
7. My New Joint
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 159 reviews
Full bar and tapas style menu offered at this wonderful new lounge that is located above the Square Grouper Bar and Grill. Offering fresh shucked oysters, peel and eat shrimp by the pound and half pound at the raw bar. Cheese and Chocolate Fondues as well as an array of sliders and salads are on the menu. Check out the menu on this site or on our website. Live Music!!
Reviewed By kmsmolen - Crestview, Florida
We stopped in after having dinner downstairs at the Square Grouper. The place was bustling but we got a hightop table and sat down to listen to the music and have a cocktail. The acoustics for the music are very poor -- we were unable to really hear the singer, and overly loud and in other areas
8. Bagel Island Cafe
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 140 reviews
Reviewed By Jim S - Clearwater, Florida
We stopped for lunch and enjoyed a very good Cuban sandwich. The cinnamon rolls were great as dessert. They opened extra days to support cleanup crews after hurricane Irma. We will eat here again.
9. Looe Key Tiki Bar & Grill
Overall Ratings
3.5 based on 244 reviews
Looe Key Tiki Bar & Grill is the most happening place in the lower keys with live entertainment nightly, the longest daily happy hour from 3-7pm, lunch and dinner specials (including a weekday $5 lunch)! Dine under the shade of our classic Tiki roof, poolside on our newly renovated deck or put your toes in the sand at our “beach” outdoor seating area. The Tiki Bar & Grill is the place to hang with the locals in laid-back keys fashion!!! Don’t forget about our onsite motel and full-service dive/snorkel shop. We also offer kayaks, rental boats, sunset and fishing charters at the resort year-round!**Please make sure to place reviews for our 3 listings in the appropriate location** -Review for Tiki Bar: please post HERE at “Looe Key Tiki & Grill” -Review for Dive & Snorkel Trips at “Looe Key Dive Center” -Review for Hotel or a combination of all 3 Resort Entities: please post at “Looe Key Reef Resort”
Reviewed By tricor43 - Cherokee, North Carolina
Great Tiki Bar, but not much more. Typical island bar food, but prices are OK. Lots of fun if it is your deal. If you have a little class, there are better choices. Put it this way, most of the local drunks love this place. But remember, in the Keys a drunk is a functioning drunk! lol Entertaining, once.
10. Good Food Conspiracy
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 99 reviews
Reviewed By Julia S - Tampa, Florida
I had the Sunrise Burger and my husband had the tofu, avocado, cheese (vegan) melt - both were awesome! Strongly recommend stopping by ESPECIALLY if you are vegan or veg! The location is also a nice little health store with some fresh produce. Staff was friendly and attentive. Really, a very nice find!!!
