Location: Wabash
Top Restaurants in Wabash
Most Popular Pizza food in Wabash, Indiana, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pizza food in Wabash, Indiana, United States. Wabash is a city in Noble Township, Wabash County, in the U.S. state of Indiana. The population was 10,666 at the 2010 census. The city is the county seat of Wabash County.
Things to do in Wabash
1. Harvey Hinklemeyers
Overall Ratings
4 based on 58 reviews
Brand new restaurant in Wabash, has previous locations in Peru and Kokomo, Indiana.
Reviewed By Paul S
Stopped in for late lunch. Ordered Chicken Cacciatore meal. Food had a good flavor, chicken was a deep fried chicken patty, that was disappointing. Pasta was cooked well, Red sauce had a nice flavor, with no kick back. Sauce lacked any veggies or mushrooms. Garlic bread was goodTypical Indiana atmosphere.I would go back.
2. Wabash Pizza King
Overall Ratings
4 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By Nanci R
Hoosiers will instantly recognize PK. Signature pizzas, strombolis and more. Their pizzas are memorable. Not many grind their pepperoni and load it on!
3. Goodfella's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Also serving 210 E. Main St. North Manchester, IN 46962
Reviewed By onestoneybeach
After a fun-filled day visiting Historic Wabash, we were exhausted and hungry so opted for pizza delivery to the Charley Creek Inn. Goodfella's was a fantastic choice ! Their prices were very reasonable and the sauce on the pizza and meatballs was out of this world !
4. Pizza Hut
Reviewed By Amusementparkguy
Normally, when I eat at a Pizza Hut, I know what to expect. I have been to this one before on my way back home from Indiana Beach amusement resort. But this time, things were far less than they should have been.This Pizza Hut offers and evening buffet on weekends. Most Pizza Hut restaurants do not offer anything but a lunch buffet, if even that. When a friend and I arrived, the restaurant was very busy. The buffet was still going on, so we opted to have that for dinner. The server was very polite and efficient. She told us that though there wasn't much left on the buffet, not to worry because more would be coming out soon.We approached the buffet bar. My friend started with a salad. I am not much of a salad person, so I looked over the pizza selections that were left. Only a couple slices on the buffet remained: a supreme (which I cannot eat everything on those), a pepperoni and mushroom (can't do the mushrooms or have mushroom juices), and one other. Since I could not eat any of that, I sat down to wait on the promised pizzas that were supposed to have been coming out to the buffet.25 minutes later, NO NEW pizzas had been brought to the buffet. I motioned to our server when she was able to walk by (still busy with other customers) and asked if more pizza would be coming out to the buffet, specifically a pepperoni pizza as that is the type I eat the most of. She went to check. The answer was, "No. They are NOT bringing any more pizzas to the buffet." REALLY?! After all that time and the promise to get more pizza, there was nothing. Good grief!I know it wasn't the servers fault. She was only telling me what the manager/kitchen crew told her to tell guests coming in for pizza. She apologized. I ended up ordering off the menu, which took another 15-20 minutes to get my food. This is normally not a problem, but had I known the buffet was over, I never would have ordered it. She did not charge me for the buffet as I did not take anything from it. If the manager of this Pizza Hut is reading this, please take heed. DO NOT continue to let people think more food will be brought to the buffet when it won't. It was a waste of my time sitting there. And when you do have a buffet going on, please make sure you bring out more than just ONE pepperoni pizza, especially when you are busy. That is your most popular pizza, and one pizza is not going to be enough for everyone who would like some. It goes faster than the others.Though I am sure this is an isolated incident, it has left a bad enough taste in my mouth to avoid this Pizza Hut the next several times I am in the area. My friend and I usually eat at the Ponderosa Steak House close by, but we chose to do something different this year. It was a mistake.On the positive side, once the food finally got to me, it did taste very good. The quality was still there. The server did a great job. But miscommunication about the buffet was very bad!
5. Papa John's
Reviewed By SteelerFanTransplant
Ordered a pizza online for carry out. Pizza was ready on time. The crust was okay, sauce had a good flavor, and a decent amount of cheese, but the toppings were very sparce. Onion, green pepper, and mushroom ordered.
