Location: Rye Brook
Top Restaurants in Rye Brook
Most Popular Pizza food in Rye Brook, New York, United States
Best Pizza restaurants nearby. Discover the best Pizza food in Rye Brook. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Pizza restaurants near you.. Rye Brook is a village in Westchester County, New York, United States, within the town of Rye. The population was 9,347 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Rye Brook
10. Antonio's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By Aniello1025
Been coming here for years. Pizza is consistently good. Sicilian slices are the best around. Definitely recommend this for lunch or something quick.
9. Michael's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 14 reviews
Michael's Pizza and Restaurant
Reviewed By MICH618
I organized a mini reunion here in October and it was a hit! The pizza is just great! The outside area was just right as the weather cooperated. It was a great place to gather & the staff was friendly & competent. Good service & drinks. I loved the pizza so much that I revisited Michael's twice more during the week while I was in the NY/CT area. The chopped salad is also worth a try. The dressing was tasty. Wish they could deliver to Florida! I'll be back!
8. Franks Pizzeria & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By scooperman
Finally found an Italian restaurant with very good food and reasonable prices in Westchester! We have family in Rye Brook and visit often, sampling many different restaurants. The food at Frank's was delicious and the portions generous. I had pasta primavera with grilled chicken in garlic and oil. The vegetables were cooked al dente and the pasta was perfect. A small salad was included with the pastas. Frank's is not fancy but the service was attentive and the ambience friendly. The menu is large and offered some interesting dishes. The pizza looked delicious. The average price of entrees was about $18 - what we paid for an appetizer at the last place we went to. We can't wait for another visit.
7. Frankie & Louie's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 23 reviews
Reviewed By BobLeblaw
Wow! I've driven by this place many times over the years, and finally got around to stopping for dinner with my wife and two friends, and we were treated to one of the best Italian meals I've ever had. My Shrimp Scarpariello was cooked to perfection. My wife's mushroom ravioli was delicious. We had the firecracker calamari and a small pizza as appetizers, and they were both awesome. Our waitress, Cindi, was AWESOME too.
6. Sunrise Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Welcome to Sunrise Pizza, where we have a passion for Italian food. Our menu offers everything you could ever want to satisfy your cravings, including an endless selection of specialty pizzas, thick and hearty soups, and a wide variety of entrees and main
Reviewed By Silverhamma
Generations of Rye children and adults have been well looked after at this downtown Rye institution. New York style pizza- check. Big salads- check. Pasta and sandwiches - check. Anything fancy or fuzzy- nope- just classic New York pizzeria fare. Sunrise's menu is limited to NY style pizza, sandwiches, red sauce pasta, and salads but all are done well and with care. They are truly great with kids- so don't hesitate to bring your over-hungry brood in. Great place to stop in after a ball game or for a quick bite before heading to the train. It is more or less in train parking lotTry the lasagna pizza- it's fantastic!Oh- Make sure you bring your cash. They don't take credit cards- though they have been know to offer credit until your next visit when you're light- which is nice!Enjoy one of down town Rye's favorites!
5. John's of Arthur Avenue
Reviewed By BobLeblaw
It's a tough game, opening a pizzeria (and Italian restaurant) in the Port Chester area, because there are so many other good ones. Thankfully for all of us, John's brings real competition to the pizza game. They make an awesome pie here, and the owner and his staff are friendly, and happy to see you. Go here. Try their pizza...you'll be back.
4. Villa Rustica Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
Reviewed By 848bobm
Suggest reserving a table on a Saturday night. Well prepared food, lots of options, pasta served very hot. Pizza quite tasty! Donât bother with the bread- not worth the effort- very hot, but tasteless.
3. T&J Pizza and Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 77 reviews
Reviewed By JDN535
Birthday Sunday afternoon dinner with my wife and two teenage daughters. Late afternoon was not crowded but place was filling up as we finished our dinner. Excellent choices. Shrimp parmigiana and Chicken Siciliana were huge portions and left us full. Excellent penne all a vodka also as well as good specials. Our waitress was friendly and attentive and food came out in a timely manner. This has to be one of the best Italian Restaurants in Westchester County. We will be back and look forward to visit8ng again soon.
2. Fortina
Overall Ratings
4 based on 46 reviews
Reviewed By BobLeblaw
Super casual, with awesome food. They have two giant wood-burning pizza ovens that cranks out awesome pies. They even have an "Original Ray's Pizza" on the menu, and I asked about that, since that claim is hotly debated in NYC, and was told that they were making a joke, since it's such a source of contention in NYC. They put it on the menu as a way to poke fun at the whole thing.
1. Coals
Overall Ratings
4 based on 110 reviews
Reviewed By Reasonable50
The pizza at Coals is worth the pilgrimage. It is that good. Just look at the rating on TA. We went on a Sunday night and C was packed by 6:30. The restaurant only serves beer and wine. However, the IPA beer selections are impressive. Also, the atmosphere is very casual. Easy Peasy. Highly recommend.
