Location: Macedon
Top Restaurants in Macedon
Most Popular Pizza food in Macedon, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pizza food in Macedon, New York, United States. Macedon is a town in Wayne County, New York, United States. The population was 9,148 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Macedon
10. Prosecco Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 102 reviews
Prosecco Italian Restaurant & Jazz Bar is one of the best choices if your looking for an authentic Italian restaurant in the Finger Lakes Region. We are located in Farmington, NY on Route 332, just a short drive from Exit 44 on the New York State Thruway.
Reviewed By tcimike
Enjoyed a family get together to celebrate a family birthday. Lively happy hour bar experience to enjoy a toast before sitting down for dinner. Often there is live music on Fridays which adds to the overall experience. Shared the Sicilian calamari and arancini (mini risotto balls with bacon and leeks).Enjoyed the warm signature bread right out of the oven- delicious! Evening specials are not to be missed in addition to the expansive menu. Table selections included blue crab stuffed homemade ravioli, gnocchi with vodka sauce with scallops, veal marsala, meat balls and arugula caprese salad and pork shank special. Mini cannoli to celebrate birthday Italian style.Brittany our personable waitress added to our very enjoyable evening with her attention and warmness. Have enjoyed this restaurant many times with friends and family. Food is always consistent along with the service.Mike, thank you for choosing to celebrate with us! We hope that everyone enjoyed the Sicilian calamari and arancini with our house bread. We're lucky to have such loyal customers like yourself, and we hope to continue to serve you for many years to come. We'll see you next time!
9. Lucca Wood-Fire Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 178 reviews
Reviewed By 245JimM
We needed to refuel and rehydrate after a hard hike at the nearby Ganondaga State Historical Site. The place is clean and inviting, staffed by friendly people. Cathie and I started the meal by sharing a Cesars Salad, followed up by a "make your own 16-inch pizza" of several ingredients. We each had two drinks. The price after tax and before tip was $65. That's a little on the pricey side, but we have a half-pizza left over. Service was great, as was the food.
8. Mark's Pizzeria
Reviewed By _vacation_dreamer_SB
Mark's pizza is surpassed only by the outstanding attention to customer service. Pros include: large menu, fresh ingredients, excellent on-line ordering service, respectful and informed employees, fair prices, and access to coupons.Only con is it is very difficult to make a left out of their parking lot.
7. TK's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
When you're in the mood for a slice of pizza that will overtake your mouth with the robust flavors of fresh tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and hints of garlic and Italian spices, visit the finest pizza place in Fairport, NY. TK's Pizzeria is the place to go
Reviewed By Jerold J
T K's has been our favorite for many years. We get pizza from all the other places, but keep coming back to T K's because we like it the best.Although there is seating, the interior isn't much. I'll stop in for lunch if by myself but otherwise we use them for takeout.I've read a couple of comments about the owner being rude. He is matter-of-fact, and maybe a bit blunt, but I've never considered him rude. He is hard working and extremely fair. One time I came in at the tail end of lunch service (they close immediately after until evening) and he was done serving. He had a couple of slices left but just gave them to me because they'd been sitting for a bit. Anyway, great spot, give them a try.
6. Mark's Pizzeria Incorporated
Reviewed By Rob C
I would highly recommend Mark's.... a great local chain which offers a thick crust pizza. Look for coupons in the phone books and on-line. They also offer a good gluten free pizza, for those that need it.
5. Mark's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 15 reviews
Reviewed By Senseiyukidaruma
New to the area we are in search of the type of Pizza we know and love. Sorry to say it was not here. Salvatores is better and a little closer to what we like. Sorry
4. Nima's Pizza
Overall Ratings
3 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By Freba
Our order took forever!!!! But when my daughter's calzone came, it was the biggest one we had ever seen! She had ordered a two-item pepper and mushroom calzone, but when it came it was pepperoni and mushroom! It was good, anyway! One calzone would have been enough for at least two of us!
3. Marks' Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 70 reviews
Reviewed By TravelBoss79
Staff was awesome. Very friendly. Pretty fast for fresh made. They let us have our pizza with 4 quarters being different so we had a smorgasbord of choices. Delicious pizza and salad was pretty good too. Salads were of generous proportions. Would eat here again.
2. Mozzeroni's Pizza & Pasta
Overall Ratings
3 based on 9 reviews
Reviewed By Larry W
I stopped into this local sub/pizza shop yesterday as I was passing through Macedon. I wanted lunch "on-the-go," and was hoping for something as good as this stores predecessor, the old "Shell's" sub shop. What I found was OK, but not up to that level, at least not yet. The place is still relatively new, although it's been open long enough that it should have had the kinks worked out already.The staff who took my order seemed a bit confused by my request (a chicken-salad wrap), which they apparently didn't have, which wasn't a problem. But the two people up on the ordering station did have to consult the chef a few times,which made me think that perhaps he was the supervisor, which he wasn't. When I changed my order to a "club wrap," they all seemed confused by his question (the chef's) about "what kind of club sandwich?" No worries...they did get it straightened out. But then the chef made me wonder even more as he spent a few minutes reading the instruction sheet on how to make the wrap,which didn't seem like that tough a topic.I took my wrap to go, along with a soda, and ate it in the car. The contents of the wrap itself were pretty good; nice mixture of turkey, bacon, lettuce & mayo. But the actual wrap (the flour tortilla, or whatever it is that holds it together) tasted funky...just not good. I don't know if the whole wheat flour in the wraps had gone rancid, but I found myself eating around most of the wrap itself, and not eating the ends. BTW, the service itself was OK...friendly and intent on getting me what I wanted.Overall, the wrap contents were good, but the wrap itself was not. It wasn't the cheapest of wraps, either, as the wrap and the soda came to about $11.00. It was edible, but I probably won't go back there.
Where to eat American food in Macedon: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Pontilloâs Gananda Pizzeria
Reviewed By Larry W
We ordered all nine sheet pizzas for our annual party this weekend, and the pizza was up to their normal standards of excellence. The owner, Dave, will do anything to please the customers. This weekend, he gave us a nice discount and recommended the perfect mix of pizzas for our guests. I especially enjoyed the Hawaiian pizza, with smoky ham and sweet pineapple chunks...outstanding! I highly recommend this pizzeria for either take-out or eating in.
