Location: Chittenango
Top Restaurants in Chittenango
Most Popular Pizza food in Chittenango, New York, United States
Reviews on Pizza food in Chittenango, New York, United States. Chittenango is a village located in Madison County, New York, in the United States. The village is in the south part of the Town of Sullivan. The population was 5,081 at the 2010 census. This is the birthplace of L. Frank Baum, author of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz.
Things to do in Chittenango
1. Nina's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant of Chittenango
Overall Ratings
4 based on 45 reviews
Reviewed By dheugel
Great Italian food, wonderful service, authentic cooking by native Italian Chef.Go back during every visit the last three years.Highly recommend for small or large group.
2. Wicked Good Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By 94741233
I visited WGP back in November 2015 and wrote a review for TripAdvisor, giving it a very good rating. Today's return experience was a disappointment, and I am dropping my rating to average.Everything I said about decor in my previous review still applies: dull and uninteresting.Unlike the last time, this time the pizza crust was bready and not very crisp, suggesting either a problem with the dough or a too-low oven temperature; it failed to impress me. Our group also ordered mozzarella sticks to share, and the tomato sauce that came with them was thin, watery, and not very flavorful.On the bright side, the woman who took our order at the counter and brought it to our table was very pleasant and friendly.Don't get me wrong, the pizza was still okay, and I may still stop in for a slice if in the area. It just wasn't any better than average this time.
3. New York Pizzeria
Reviewed By me13037
I had bad service here repeatedly, but kept eating there because Chittenango isn't chock full of eateries. However, I experienced some of the worst service imaginable ...after treating my like an inconvenience, screwing up my total and making me wait around for my order...when I finally was leaving they even accused me of stealing my pizza!It is kind of a long story, but I was so mad I posted my story here:http://chittenangopizzanightmare.weebly.com/----Long story short...They will never see another red cent from this guy.
