Most Popular Pizza food in Brewster, New York, United States

May 30, 2020 Roger Rusk

Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Brewster. Brewster is a village within the town of Southeast in Putnam County, New York, United States. Its population was 2,390 at the 2010 census. The village, which is the most densely populated portion of the county, was named for two early farmer landowners, Walter and James Brewster.
Things to do in Brewster

10. Five Brothers Pizza & Pasta

2505 Carmel Ave, Brewster, NY 10509-1155 Pizza +1 845-278-4500
Five Brothers Pizza & Pasta

Reviewed By Karen M

While driving on I-84 from East to West, a severe hunger pain hit us. We left the highway at Exit 19 and found this establishment by accident. The sign in the front said that the place was for Pizza and Pasta. But the establishment could rate as a full service restaurant with Italian accent.AMBIENCE : Utilitarian, clean, tables covered with red/white checkers of plastic.MENU : Very extensive, from Soup to Desserts.FOOD : We only had slices of Pizza with bottles of local Root Beer. Pizza had a wonderful appearance and texture. A younger of two men at the counter said that their Calamari Fritti were home made, sliced and breaded fresh.SERVICE : Very Good !! CONCLUSION : This will be our destination eatery when we travel on Ip-84.

9. Taormina's Pizzeria-Ristorante

278 N Brewster Rd, Brewster, NY 10509-2848 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner +1 845-279-1922
Taormina's Pizzeria-Ristorante

Reviewed By AcapulcoFred

Just looking for a place to eat and this was what we picked. To tell you the truth... this was the best pizza ever. All I can say it try it you will love it.

8. Moonlight Cafe

850 Route 22 Stark Plaza, Brewster, NY 10509-1534 American, Pizza, Cafe, Soups Lunch, Dinner +1 845-279-9000
Moonlight Cafe

Reviewed By JS-10hands

We stumbled upon this marvelous little gem of a restaurant. We just happen to be lucky enough to work right next door to this phenomenal eatery.Moonlight Café and Caterers in Brewster, NY is simply superb. They offered a plethora of unique freshly prepared dishes, on an extensive menu with specials that change on a daily basis. It's your choice of some really tasty "Home Made" appetizers, soups, pizzas artisan sandwiches and plainly an overabundance of entrées, not to mention a very extensive array of mouth-watering desserts too... Oh and did I forget to mention that they are also Vegetarian / Vegan friendly. Everything on the menu is more than reasonably priced and the portions are large and fulfilling. What really impressed me, even as much as the food, was the service and friendliness of the staff. My wife Mindi and I were greeted "super nicely" by our counter-person and she could not have been more helpful in explaining and describing all of the menu items to us. We felt welcomed and appreciated and that to me was the best part of the meal. We highly recommend the Moonlight Café at 850 Route 22 in Brewster, NY. You can be sure that we will go out of our way to frequent this establishment. (Or at least walk Next Door at lunchtime). If you enjoy genuinely good food that is prepared by bona fide "Professional Chefs," as much as we do, then you've got to try the Moonlight Café In Brewster, NY. Just tell them that you saw them on TripAdvisor®. :-)

7. Pizza Place and Trattoria II

35 Main St, Brewster, NY 10509-1482 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner +1 845-279-4114

Reviewed By ClevelandBratticus

We were going to order dinner for 4 and we recommended this place to our friends who were with us because Pizza Place had told us that they had gluten free pizzas. AFTER our friends ordered their pies, Pizza Place informed us that they don't have gf pizzas. This contradicts what they told us 10 minutes earlier. We ordered 1 pie anyway but it was delivered without plates or napkins even though they provided these for our friends. Can't recommend.

10 Things to Do in Brewster That You Shouldn't Miss

6. Sinapi Pizzeria

1583 Route 22, Brewster, NY 10509-7002 Italian, Pizza Dinner, Lunch Takeout, Table Service +1 845-278-9632
Overall Ratings

4 based on 17 reviews

Reviewed By Cynhoff

They have a pretty traditional Italian menu. I have never had a bad meal there. They do a brisk take-out business at dinner time. The wait staff are the same people behind the counter, so you sort of need to flag someone down for everything, but no one seems to mind.

Where to Eat in Brewster: The Best Restaurants and Bars

5. Portofinos Pizza & Pasta

983 Route 22, Brewster, NY 10509 Italian, Pizza Dinner, Lunch Wheelchair Accessible [email protected] +1 845-363-1024
Portofinos Pizza & Pasta

Reviewed By Michelle A

I am a pizzanista! Portofino's is the best!! Their pizza and sauce is delicious. The owners are fun, friendly and have great personalities. (I used to work at the wine store next door) Portofino's is the best of the best.... Close your eyes and point to anything on the menu, you will not be disappointed!

New York, United States Food Guide: 5 Diner food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Brewster

4. Prato Trattoria

1892 Route 6, Carmel, NY 10512-2355 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner Takeout, Reservations, Seating, Wheelchair Accessible, Highchairs Available, Serves Alcohol, Table Service +1 845-225-6914
Overall Ratings

4 based on 37 reviews

Prato Trattoria

Reviewed By Peter W

Food from pizza to restaurant entrees was superb. Friendly helpful staff throughout. Pleasant individual booths cozy. Discovered recently and have now been back three times and plan to return frequently in the future. Now my go to Italian place. Recommend it most highly. If you go you will not be disappointed.

Top 5 Mexican food in Brewster, New York, United States

3. Gaetano's Pizza & Calzone

100 Independent Way Ste E, Brewster, NY 10509-6301 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible [email protected] +1 845-278-9500
Overall Ratings

4 based on 41 reviews

Gaetano's Pizza & Calzone

Reviewed By Picky_Eater_From_NY

We had a pizza and chicken parm sandwich. The level of salt was unbearable. Half and hour after eating 2 slices of pizza, my throat still burns and I can't shake the overwhelming lingering taste of salt. We called to advise them of the problem, and the only response was "Thanks, click". They couldn't have cared less. By By Gaetano. Never again.

Where to eat Italian food in Brewster: The Best Restaurants and Bars

2. Mezza Luna Pizzeria & Restaurant

1151 Route 22, Brewster, NY 10509-4322 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner, Brunch, Drinks Takeout, Seating, Table Service, Reservations, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol +1 845-279-1800
Overall Ratings

4 based on 57 reviews

Mezza Luna Pizzeria & Restaurant

Classic meets modern in this Manhattan-style Pizzeria and Restaurant. From our Italian classics to our daily specials and hand-crafted New York style pizza, every diner is sure to find something exceptional that will leave their taste buds saying "WOW!" W

Reviewed By NYCOandbeyond

After seeing the renovations to this restaurant and reading recent reviews of Mezza Luna, I was excited to visit with my family tonight. I am sorry to say that I was disappointed. For starters, we ordered the one of the “special” martinis, which turned out to be nothing more than watered-down cosmos. When these arrived, along with stale bread, at our table, I should have left right then, but we carried on and ordered another special, the tuna tartare, along with tortellini soup and our entrees. Sadly, the tuna special was rubbery and previously frozen; only the fresh avocados that arrived with it made the dish edible. The tortellini soup was average, and our entrees, when they arrived, featured overcooked, mushy pasta and sauce that I could have made better at home. The veal was tough and the shrimp parmesan was not fresh (clearly previously frozen). The lasagna, however, made with fresh mozzarella and ground beef, somewhat made up for these other dishes. The glasses of tasty Pinot Grigio we ordered after the first round of drinks also helped Mezza Luna’s cause, as did the friendly service. Unfortunately, the bill, at $157 for four of us which did not include dessert but did include charges for each soda refill (which the server neglected to tell us when she asked if my kids wanted more), was the dealbreaker, not because we didn’t expect to pay so much, but because we expected far better quality for the price. In short, if you’re looking for high quality Italian food, proceed a little further up the road, where you will find much better at a similar price point.

Most Popular American food in Brewster, New York, United States


1620 Route 22 Intersection of Rt 312, Brewster, NY 10509 Italian, Pizza Lunch, Dinner Takeout, Reservations, Seating, Parking Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Table Service, Television +1 845-279-2233
Overall Ratings

4 based on 96 reviews


Reviewed By Tara R

Absolutely my favorite!!! The best Italian food !! Atmosphere was amazing!! Wait staff superb!! Love ❤️ it there!!

Best Latin food near Brewster, New York, United States

ThingsTodoPost © 2018 All rights reserved.