Most Popular Italian food in McKinleyville, California, United States

January 12, 2020 Vivienne Hutton

Find out what Italian restaurants to try in McKinleyville. McKinleyville (formerly, Minorsville) is a census-designated place (CDP) in Humboldt County, California, United States. McKinleyville is located 5.25 miles (8.4 km) north of Arcata, at an elevation of 141 feet (43 m). The population was 15,177 at the 2010 census, up from 13,599 at the 2000 census. This unincorporated community is the third largest community, after Eureka and Arcata, on the far North Coast and larger than five of seven cities in the county. It is also the location of the Arcata-Eureka Airport, the largest airport in Humboldt County and the region.
Things to do in McKinleyville

1. Mazzotti's Ristorante Italiano

773 8th St, Arcata, CA 95521-6203 Pizza, Italian Lunch, Dinner, Late Night Takeout, Seating, Parking Available, Street Parking, Free Off-Street Parking, Television, Highchairs Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Accepts American Express, Accepts Mastercard, Accepts Visa, Digital Payments, Free Wifi, Accep +1 707-822-1900 http://www.mazzottis.com/
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
Overall Ratings

4 based on 184 reviews

Mazzotti's Ristorante Italiano

Mazzotti's on the Plaza features an exquisite menu, with exciting daily specials. In addition to beer and wine, we offer a full service bar. Seating at the bar in Arcata provides a comfortable place to wait for friends or a table. The atmosphere is warm a

Reviewed By danielgale

I really want to love this restaurant - the atmosphere is great, especially for a family but the food consistently is only okay. I've eaten here multiple times over the years since they opened up on the plaza, as well as multiple times at their old Eureka location. The Arcata location is spacious and accommodating, especially for a family with kids. The food is okay but it is nothing great, and for the cost of most of the dishes, they really need to figure out how to kick it up a notch or two. We ate here earlier this month for a big family outing. I knew in the back of my head the food would only be "okay" but we had 10-11 people in the party and it was no problem to get a reservation for a party of this size, so we went with it. Between all of us, we ordered a wide array of dishes, some of which were "pretty good", others somewhere between okay and good, and others just flat out bad. The worst was their supposed vegetable soup, which the waiter said was essentially like a minestrone. It was completely inedible - hard to imagine how you can screw up minestrone more than this but it was clear whoever made it never tasted it. An Italian restaurant should nail minestrone with their eyes closed. The salads were okay but nothing special - with all the great local produce options in this area, they really need to figure out how to do a salad right. My son ordered tortellini, which was pretty good - I don';t think it was homemade but it was good enough to pass. My father-in-law ordered the ravioli, which looked homemade and better than I've experienced here in the past. My daughter ordered a salmon dinner on polenta - the salmon was good and cooked correctly but the polenta was inedible...again, an Italian restaurant needs to figure out polenta correctly - this wasn't even close. Someone else ordered spaghetti, which was basically store-bought noodles with some marinara sauce. The sauce was fine but for the prices they charge and for being an Italian restaurant, they really should figure out homemade pasta - it's not difficult. Instead what they served is something anyone could easily make in their kitchen.I keep hoping someday this place will kick up their cuisine to make this place worth dining out here. Until then, as much as I want to like the place, I won't fool myself again into thinking it's worth the cost.

Best Seafood food near McKinleyville, California, United States

2. Abruzzi

791 8th St, Arcata, CA 95521-6234 Italian Dinner Takeout, Seating, Street Parking, Free Off-Street Parking, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Wine and Beer, Accepts American Express, Accepts Mastercard, Accepts Visa, Accepts Discover, Reservations, Table Service, Accepts Credit Cards +1 707-826-2345 http://www.abruzziarcata.com/
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
Overall Ratings

4 based on 145 reviews

Abruzzi

Abruzzi features hand-made, organic pasta and a wide array of seafood, meats and vegetarian options with mouth-watering sauces and fresh, seasonal ingredients. We also serve hand-crafted cocktails, draft beer and cider. Join us for artisan Italian fare at

Reviewed By ShazDenise

We were surprised by how much we enjoyed it here. Downstairs in a lovely arcade, it was reasonably quiet, had a lovely bar, open kitchen, decent seating and service, and the food was good. I found the portions to be average-to-large, and especially the sauces/dressings to be well developed. The potato soup was like a smooth, creamy, chunk-free chowder and delicious. The fish was fresh and excellently cooked. The salads were also very fresh and well thought out. Excellent cocktails.

Top 8 Asian food in McKinleyville, California, United States

3. Paul's Live From New York Pizza

665 Samoa Blvd, Arcata, CA 95521-6639 Pizza, Italian Lunch, Dinner Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible, Delivery +1 707-822-6199 http://paulslivefromnewyorkpizza.com
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
Overall Ratings

4 based on 47 reviews

Paul's Live From New York Pizza

Reviewed By Talisker55

If you like thin crust, New York style pizza then this is your destination. If you want thick, gooey, pre-frozen commercial cardboard then keep moving. Pizzas are made fresh right in front of you. Very large slices that you fold and enjoy. Great service, even better taste!

California, United States Food Guide: 9 Pizza food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in McKinleyville

4. PastaLuego

791 8th St Suite 1, Arcata, CA 95521-6234 Italian Lunch Takeout, Parking Available, Street Parking, Free Off-Street Parking, Wheelchair Accessible, Accepts Credit Cards +1 707-825-0108 http://cocopastaluego.com/menu
PastaLuego

Reviewed By keystonexl

Pastaluego is an experience you don't want to miss. Fresh pasta, ravioli so superb you won't be able to resist. Homemade sauces to go along with garlic bread ready to go in the oven. The deli case is all imported Italian meats and cheeses. Their sandwiches you will always remember. Then the retail items finish your experience. Coco whom is the force behind Pastaluego is a delight. This is one place when in Arcata that is a must see.

Top 3 Fast Food food in McKinleyville, California, United States

5. La Trattoria

30 Sunnybrae Ctr, Arcata, CA 95521-6742 Italian Dinner, Lunch Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible, Reservations, Seating, Parking Available, Free Off-Street Parking, Serves Alcohol, Wine and Beer, Accepts Mastercard, Accepts Visa, Accepts Credit Cards, Table Service +1 707-822-6101 http://www.latrattoriaarcata.com/
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
Overall Ratings

4 based on 48 reviews

La Trattoria

La Trattoria is a small family run restaurant with a limited menu that features traditional Italian dishes not commonly found in the States. We use only local and seasonal produce, buying direct from Humboldt county farmers. All our meats are sustainably

Reviewed By 720Davis_M

As stated, this is a small, off the beaten path Italian restaurant that serves very good to excellent Italian cuisine. Their food is fresh and local (farm to fork style), with a rotating menu based on local seasonal food. While the setting and atmosphere is basic and no frills, it is nonetheless comfortable. We have been here many times and the service has always been pleasant and food comes out in a timely manner. Other than the house house, which is a little too generic/bland for my liking, I have enjoyed all other menu items I have eaten here over the years. Would highly recommend this place.

Best Bar food near McKinleyville, California, United States

ThingsTodoPost © 2018 All rights reserved.