Location: Fayetteville
Top Restaurants in Fayetteville
Most Popular Italian food in Fayetteville, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Fayetteville, New York, United States. Fayetteville is a village located in Onondaga County, New York, United States. As of the 2010 U.S. Census, the village had a population of 4,373. The village is named after the Marquis de Lafayette, a national hero of both France and the United States. It is part of the Syracuse Metropolitan Statistical Area.
Things to do in Fayetteville
10. Pavone's Pizza & Eatery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 29 reviews
Reviewed By rfsalomone
This is on the list of my top three pizza places in Syracuse. Pizza is excellent. Always thin and they cook it perfectly. Ingredients are always fresh. Wings are average but I donât really order those very often. They have a full menu but the pizza is so good I never tried any of it. My personal favorites are plain cheese and they make a a white pizza with fresh tomatoes that is delicious. I normally go on lunch and you usually have to wait but itâs worth it.
9. Mario & Salvo's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 53 reviews
Reviewed By Sunshine1340
Called for delivery of pizza and wings. I asked for my wings hot, extra crispy and light on the sauce. When delivered I was ready to dive into the pizza. Hard to believe but the pizza was extra crispy hot and little sauce. I called to complain and told them when I ordered the kid was not paying any attention and he asked my address 3 times. They then asked if i had ordered my pizza that way. Really? Really?? Yeah I wanted an over done dry hot pizza that is inedible. Wings were undercooked drowned in hot sauce and only 2 drummies and all wings. Will give them 1 more chance but thatâs it. Too many other good pizza places. Did I say really???
8. Joey's Classic Italian Dining
Overall Ratings
4 based on 569 reviews
We are a family owned restaurant serving quality Italian food since 1982. We are located off of Carrier Circle in Syracuse - New York State Thruway Exit #35
Reviewed By 553rogers
On our way home from a East coast vacation. Stayed at Residence Inn. Joeyâs is only a few minutes ride from RI. We arrived on a Wednesday night about 6:30. Able to get a table right away upstairs. We started with mushroom soup. Homemade and very good. I had a Caesar salad and the dressing did NOT come from a store. Great homemade dressing. Wife had the homemade Ravioli with a Very large meatball. Had to been over 8 ounces! I had the Fishermanâs platter with side fettuccine. A large portions and very tasty. Nice âby the glassâ wine list. Waitress very pleasant. Service was great. Unable to eat dessert because of large portions. Prices very reasonable. ENJOY!!
7. Grimaldi's Luna Park
Overall Ratings
4 based on 403 reviews
Reviewed By RoadWarrior_BOS
This Grimaldi's may have a family connection to the original Syracuse Grimaldi's on Erie Boulevard. But, the last name is where the connection ends. In the past, we've eaten at the original on Erie Boulevard too many times to count, and every time we had a memorable experience. From those experiences, we can not remember a single bad experience. On the other hand, this Grimaldi's in Carrier Circle did not pass muster. We experienced a situation where our reserved table was given to another party while we waited 45 minutes to an hour beyond our reservation. We in turn were a bit later provided a second rate table, and everything continued downhill from there. Our waiter had an attitude and further reinforced a bad experience. Mediocre, poorly prepared Italian food topped the experience off. The positives we took away were that we were able to have a reasonably fun time with our family, despite the negatives we experienced, because the drinks were good. Unfortunately, we were overall disappointed which is rare considering the Grimaldi family's signature contribution to the greater Syracuse restaurant scene. We'll try a different Italian restaurant in the area next time.Dear Road Warrior,We are very sorry to hear you did not enjoy your experience at Grimaldi's. I remember your party last night and the mix up, for which we are very sorry. Your party seemed very understanding of the situation and were enjoying yourselves while you waited. Not too much after you were seated and promptly waited on. We wanted to make sure your order was put in the kitchen to ensure your enjoyment. Please understand that we would have gladly offered something towards your meal had we known your displeasure. Since everyone finished their meals and were checked on repeatedly we assumed you all enjoyed your food and experience. We invite you to come back again with our compliments. Please email me @ [email protected]. Rita GrimaldiOwner
6. Pavone's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 44 reviews
Reviewed By mayorriven
Great pizza, small dining room, lots of community spirit! You never know what team, choir, or community group you will run into at Pavones. My suggestion- get the garlic broccoli white pizza. Seriously! Parking is located out back- HINT- you can walk up the sidewalk and stairs OR you can use the back entrance to the right of the food bank and grab the elevator! Enjoy!
5. Delmonico's Italian Steak
Overall Ratings
4 based on 412 reviews
Reviewed By polsson
This restaurant has wonderful food. My daughter loves their Chicken Piccata and it wasn't on the menu so they offered to make it especially for her. You can't beat that for service! We were there on a Friday and it wasn't loud even though it was busy. Food selections are terrific and the desserts are scrumptious.
4. Twin Trees Fayetteville
Overall Ratings
3 based on 11 reviews
Reviewed By snowball-6364
Our second time ordering here and probably our last. We ordered wings medium and crispy and a large pizza with pepperoni sausage and banana peppers. I picked it up and brought it home it was expensive 40 dollars plus. Our wings had no sauce on them what so ever they sat in a puddle of grease. The pizza was disgusting. It was like a deep dish Uno pizza. It was under cooked and sought and the the box soaked with grease. We didnât eat two pieces. I called the manager and we got credit for the wings. Donât know if I even want to try the wings again. The pizza is not the same as I remember from other TT locations. But they lost a customer from Manlius.
3. Pasquale's Slice of Italy
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By PamelaDeP
We arrived at 9:35 on a Saturday evening, and the restaurant closes at ten. We asked if it was ok to order, and the staff were very hospitable. We chose to eat in and were not rushed even though it was close to their closing time. We chose a Caesar salad, which was so large that it filled a large wooden bowl. We each had a generous portion of salad and took home the remaining third. We each had a slice of tomato pie which was good. We also each had a rice ball which was delicious - vegetarian (cheese and rice, no meat). We shared an order of garlic knots and they were flavorful and the right texture.
2. Carrabba's Italian Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 140 reviews
Reviewed By UpstateNySimplyme
Had dinner with several friends. Several of us ordered Gluten Free. Carrabbaâs Gluten Free pasta is very tasty. The cannoli cake was divine and not gluten free. Great dinner, great friends, reasonable prices, good service makes for a great night
1. Arad Evans Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 169 reviews
Housed in an 1840's Federalist-style residence, The Arad Evans Inn provides an unforgettable dining experience. Exceptional choices, enhanced by attentive service attuned to your personal dining mood. The Arad Evans Inn offers dinner nightly in the main d
Reviewed By tomticket
It was both Mother's Day and SU graduation. Probably the busiest day of the year for this restaurant which is perfect for special occasions. We had reservations for 11 and a private room. We ordered prix fixe from a special Mother's Day menu which had many choices. I observed that everyone cleaned their plate. My meal was phenomenal. I would say that the escargot were the best I ever had. The waitresses gave us a lot of attention. It was a perfect dining experience. .
