Location: Webster
Top Restaurants in Webster
Most Popular American food in Webster, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Webster, New York, United States. Ronald W. Nesbitt (R; 2006-present)
Things to do in Webster
10. Stoneyard American Beer Hall And Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 37 reviews
Reviewed By Nyneve5
Just had a great lunch on the patio at the Stoneyard American Beer Hall and Grill. We only saw one page of the beer menu and still had a hard time choosing our beers. Both were great and very reasonably priced. I think I had the better of the two meals. I had a BBQ pizza with smoked pork loin, sliced green apples and Gorgonzola. It was incredible. I had to take half home as it was large. The service was very attentive. We will definitely return.
9. Flaherty's Three Flags Webster
Overall Ratings
4 based on 116 reviews
Reviewed By BHM7248
We live in Webster, but only go to Flaherty's once in a while. Our recent meal there was excellent in every way. Plenty of draft beer selections, including 3 IPA's, with samples provided. Lobster bisque never disappoints. My wife went with the Flaherty's melt with corned beef, which she said was extremely tender, plentiful and also quite tasty. Their prices are still reasonable for the bisque, sandwiches and beer. Our server was cheerful and prompt. Again, we will stop by Flaherty's more often in the future.
8. Brimont Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 60 reviews
Reviewed By bensson
I was all prepared to write about the great local restaurant that "I" discovered last night. After reading all the other reviews I found out that many locals had been there before and most (all?) gave it glowing reviews. No sense repeating all those who agree with me in their reviews, so let's just say the place is wonderful, glorious, marvelous, tremendous, friendly and a diamond. So read no further. Get up off your butt and go there. You will be so happy. g
7. UNO Chicago Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 100 reviews
Reviewed By Steve C
Yes - UNO's has lots of choices and hardly treats as if they are a franchise....but they should be an early choice for pizza. They truly have more creative, better variety and higher quality pizza then most places. The others often do minimum pizza types and cut quality in order to have any price margin/profit...UNO's doesn't rely on Pizza only. We had both their deep dish and their thin versions and both were excellent. Plenty of toppings and the dough was tasty and perfectly cooked. Toppings went all the way to the edges and were plentiful. Only warning....there are good size. We will easily get 3 or more meals out of the pizza's. One was heavy on the pepperoni, another was heavily meat filled and one was a vegetable pizza,,,,colorful and rich with veggies.Special mention to our server, Morgan. She was industrious - helpful and had a knack for balancing her great smile and friendly demeanor without at all being fake or having to work hard at it. She made us all feel welcomed and comfortable as if she sincerely loved what she did...and it showed.
6. Hedges 9 Mile Point Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 219 reviews
Reviewed By andrewkM8828WE
I wanted to bring my husband to Hedges for lunch to celebrate his birthday. I had been before but he hadn't. I made a reservation for 1:00 we were seated in a few minutes, we ordered a drink that the bartender didn't know how to make. We waited for that, then we ordered, neither one of us had eaten all day it was now 1:30. A rain storm started and about 2:00 they lost power, we still have nothing to eat. We were told there wasn't a problem because they had generators. Then the hostess announces if you haven't ordered we can't take your order. That's fair enough we ordered. Then the waitress comes by and said we can't fill your order because we can't get things started up whatever that meant??? They also announced that they would be delivering the checks for the drinks. There were a couple tables that this happened to and they were complaining audibly. I could not believe tht after all of that they wouldn't even cover our drinks. I've been spreading the sad story and people said we should have gotten up and left without paying but I left the cash on the table with a tip but I do regret it. We left at 2:30.
5. Pub 235
Overall Ratings
4 based on 126 reviews
We offer a full lunch and dinner menu including specialty pizzas, sandwiches made with meats that we roast in house, salads, burgers, entrees and more. We have a full bar with traditional offerings, in addition to showcasing local favorites.
Reviewed By 15lesliej
Stopped at Pub 235 for lunch with colleagues- what a nice surprise, haven't been there for years since it was Hank's. They have retained the classic Beef on Weck on the menu if you are missing the past. The waitress was enthusiastic and knowledgable. The daily vegetable was snap peas which was a nice change from the usual side. Great salads and sandwiches, I had the Chicken French sandwich which came with a very generous amount of French sauce for dipping. Outdoor seating was enjoyable as well.
4. Maa's Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 90 reviews
Reviewed By JrMushroom
Good coffee, gyros, all day breakfast in a little diner in Webster. It is about what you would expect from a place known for good, solid food.
3. Mama Lor's Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 147 reviews
Reviewed By womenfly_1
We have eaten here several times. Once for breakfast and once for dinner. Breakfast was delishous and reasonably priced. I had the Greek Pasta for dinner and got a salad with it. It was tasty and moderately priced. My husband had the meatloaf dinner and said it was very good. Weâll definitely go again.
2. T's Family Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 169 reviews
Serves breakfast and lunch only.
Reviewed By Denise L
My husband ordered a western omelette that came with home fries. It was quite large and filling! The home fries were very good as well. I ordered the 1/2 sandwich and soup combo. Chose the onion soup but was disappointed. Not enough beef flavor, bread and a slice of provolone, found it lacking. The turkey sandwich had lots of meat, a bit of mayo on white bread. Only ok. Saw a great looking reuben go by to another table that looked great. Also, most breakfast items looked very well done and appetizing. Probably will stop again but make other food choices. Waitress took a while to get to us for the check.
1. Village Bakery & Cafe
Reviewed By Steve C
Surprise your wife, he thought....Take her to a new breakfast place, he thought...it'll be cool. Such a poor staffing plan. 1 guy had r leaves of bread...waited and put them back and left....we waited 8 minutes just to order oatmeal and a standard sandwich...still waiting after 11 more minutes. I don't really care how it tastes or if its fresh... ok....just got it.ooks good, however, not what I ordered and cold.Steve, thank you very much for your feedback. I'd like to apologize on behalf of the entire VBC team for the issues you experienced during your last visit. This is certainly not our standard and not what you should expect from us. Please accept our deepest apologies. If you're open to it, please send me an email with your dining information so we can continue the conversation. Thank you again and I look forward to hearing from you. Therese O.Guest Relations [email protected]
