Location: Sussex
Top Restaurants in Sussex
Most Popular American food in Sussex, Wisconsin, United States
Reviews on American food in Sussex, Wisconsin, United States. Sussex is a village in Waukesha County, Wisconsin, United States. It is approximately 19 miles (31 km) northwest of Milwaukee and 9 miles (14 km) north of Waukesha. The village is 7.24 square miles (19 km) at an elevation of 930 feet. The population was 10,518 at the 2010 census. It is part of the Milwaukee metropolitan area.
Things to do in Sussex
10. Palmer's Steakhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 288 reviews
Reviewed By Lisa H
You can't help but become a regular after you dine here once. The atmosphere and great service compliment the amazing menu. I have yet to try something here I did not like. Their wine list never disappoints and it is well worth the drive out to Lake Country if you aren't from the area. So happy we have this local gem!Lisa,Thank you so much for the 5 star review and kind words! We are thrilled to hear you loved all your meals and the wine list as well!We hope to see you again soon!
9. Mr B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse - Brookfield
Overall Ratings
4 based on 320 reviews
Mr. B's Steakhouse provides spacious, handsome surroundings with characteristics of an Italian countryside. We are a classic Italian Steakhouse featuring classic steaks and fresh seafood; offering only the best ingredients and service to create an unparal
Reviewed By mirkom833
I had a business dinner at this place after a while and I was disappointed to see how bad the restaurant developed in a year or so. The steak, exceptional in the past, tasted average if ever. Prices though remained high thus, the result in terms of value for money is now somehow halved!Donât go there as long as they are not back to the usual quality level, of is just not worth the money.
8. 5 O'Clock Club
Overall Ratings
4 based on 191 reviews
5 O'Clock Club, in Pewaukee, WI, is the area's leading family restaurant serving Pewaukee, Milwaukee and surrounding areas. We offer sandwiches, burgers, steak, fish, desserts and more. For your next meal, visit 5 O'Clock Club in Pewaukee.
Reviewed By beth r
5 of us went out to celebrate a 60th birthday of a friend. This was a new experience for all of us...and the birthday boy likes supper clubs. The restaurant itself was quite quaint and over all the food was good, however some of the menu selections for dinner left me a bit up in the air. I was looking for a steak, and there were limited choices. The tenderloin intrigued me, however it was only offered with shrimp and scallops and I have a shellfish allergy. I was offered a tenderloin sandwich...there are no other options. So I went totally into left field with grandma's fried chicken. Well let me tell you ...grandma must have died of high cholesterol because the half chicken on my plate had at least a 1/4 inch of breading fried onto it and the grease flowed out onto my plate when I pulled the skin back. The chicken itself was moist but I am not sure it was 100% cooked. The rest of our party ordered the specials for Saturday and they were pleased with their meals so all was not lost. It was a 60th birthday celebration and we mentioned that several times-no cake was ever offered...not a game changer but most places will offer that.
7. North Star American Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 177 reviews
Reviewed By 205KathyT
We had a private party in side room. Wait staff was attentive and limited food choices very good. The DIY Bloody Mary bar(on Sundays) was open and popular. I would return when given the opportunity. It was a little confusing to find as its nestled in a shopping area off Capitol drive. The delicious Cheesecake was from Simmas, a local bakery.
6. Mibb's & Viv's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By TheWash
This is a small town bar known for their Friday night fish fry and Saturday night fried chicken. Cash only, this is a small bar. Arrive early and prepare for a slight wait. Your server will take your order while you wait near the bar and then seat you when seating and your dinner is ready. This is not dining - this is eating, but the quality of the fish fry is superior. It's a well known place and very popular for good reason. Not appropriate for small children. Not appropriate for larger groups either. Seating is limited.
5. Artisan 179
Overall Ratings
4 based on 146 reviews
Reviewed By TheBBomb
The beet salad was delicious. Best one Iâve ever had. But The restaurant is a little pricey in my opinion. Staff was very nice, informative and efficient. They have a nice selection of beer, wine and specialty drinks. Everyone enjoyed the evening and the experience.
4. Doc's Dry Dock
Overall Ratings
4 based on 137 reviews
Doc's has proudly been serving the Lake Country area for 25+ years. We offer the freshest pizza available. Our dough is made fresh daily and we load your pizza with toppings. Our wait times may get lengthy (we're working as fast as possible), but we are v
Reviewed By 968williamrh
There are times when one doesn't want to review a restaurant for fear that people will read one's review and flock to the place making it harder to find a seat. Thus is the story of Doc's. A very small place...a few tables...a bar...and the best darn pizza around. We were tipped off by a friend to try Doc's, saying he would pay for the trip if we didn't enjoy the food. A pretty safe tip. Our sausage , mushroom, and black olive 14" pizza was more than enough for two people (we took a third home). So delicious, it makes my mouth water just writing this review. And the beer was cold...served in a frosted glass. This is our new go to place for pizza. A little out of the way, but worth the trip. The unfortunate thing for us, is we just gave up our boat on Pewaukee Lake, otherwise their dock would have been very convenient for us. Well, driving there in the convertible will have to do.This is one of my top 3 favorite reviews of all time. Thank you very much. Next time you come in, please ask if Josh is around.Thanks again!!
3. Starbucks
Reviewed By marys454lisbonwi
This is a review for our local Starbucks in Menononee Falls and others we recently visited in Vancouver and Seattle. Went to the original Starbucks in Seattle and joined many other tourists doing the same thing. Enjoyed the experience. Brought bean coffee home and was able to have it ground at my local Starbucks. The original Pikes Place did not have a grinder. I think I am going to be a loyal customer.
2. Rumors Sports Bar and Grill
Overall Ratings
3 based on 29 reviews
Reviewed By Greg A
I tried rumors again and have upgraded my rating. They really need some help in the hiring department. Seems they are desperate for help and will hire anyone who applies. I feel they don't take enough pride in their business. I can't believe how they let the bartenders choose when they close. I've personally been kicked out at 10pm along with 7 other customers. We just got there. I believe the owner does a pretty good job but just really need to take it to the next level. Service is great with a woman (Holly). Her pride in her service shows. The customer matters to her. Also if you read the previous reviews, you will notice the high reviews, they are mostly local. Sounds like friends. Sussex lacks the "really good food" status and seems like the owners attitude is, it's good enough. This place has potential but it's stuck in the group of the rest of this town's food. Mediocre at best. See the posted photos of the wings? What kind of cook or server would serve this to a customer?? BUT it's still way better than Tailgators!
1. M & M Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 30 reviews
Reviewed By larryd6578
I was looking for a place for lunch before a meeting nearby. M&M showed up on my phone's map app, so I thought we'd give it a try. But when I saw it, at first I decided to keep going - it looks a bit run down from the outside. Fortunately I was able to see some of the interior, and it looked inviting. I'm glad we stopped. The food, service, and prices were great. I had the ham steak special, with mashed potatoes, veggies, and chicken noodle soup. The interior was a bit dated, but that gives the place its charm. If I'm ever back in the area, I plan to stop by again.
