Location: Marco Island
Top Restaurants in Marco Island
Florida, United States Food Guide: 10 Seafood food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Marco Island
Best Seafood restaurants nearby. Discover the best Seafood food in Marco Island. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Seafood restaurants near you.. White beaches, a sparkling sea, a strawberry daiquiri in hand—what more do you need in a vacation? Marco Island brings visitors the best that the Ten Thousand Islands have to offer. Scavenge for seashells or hit the links for a sunny session of golf. Explore the Everglades in a swamp buggy or enjoy a rejuvenating nature hike at the Rookery Bay Reserve.
Things to do in Marco Island
10. Marek's Bar and Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 598 reviews
Reviewed By 174AlB
Our party (2 couples) selected Marekâs for a Friday evening dinner so glad we did! We made a reservation for 7:00 pm and were promptly seated. Our server Brittany was most professional and a true ambassador for Marekâs. I have traveled a lot in business - you wonât find a more professional server anywhere. Brittany explained the menu and specials and made recommendations when asked. Two in our party had the pompano special and two had the Barramundi special. Both were exceptional. The presentation was excellent and food hot - freshly prepared. One couple had the coconut shrimp - excellent. The other couple had the wedge salad which Brittany had the kitchen divide. Marekâs menu is varied with something for everyone. We highly recommend Marekâs.Thank you for your review we are glad you enjoyed your dining experience with us at Mareks!We appreciated you kind words concerning Brittanyâs service and we look forward to serving you again in the future
9. Ario
Overall Ratings
4 based on 547 reviews
Welcome to Ario, built upon the passion of a primal dining experience for the discerning global nomad. We celebrate your innate desire to explore your culinary senses by elevating every ingredient of your visit. In our casually elegant dining room, we inv
Reviewed By Traveljourneys13
During our stay at JW Marriott we dined at Ario. Our steak was cooked to perfection. We didn't care for our caesar salads. The lobster Mac & Cheese is scrumptious.Rein was our waitress. We had told her about our horrible experience with Japanese Wagyu beef and how we wanted to stay away from it! She recommended our steak choice and we were not disappointed! I originally ordered their signature cosmopolitan! It was too sweet for my palate. I did let her know that I was not happy with it and she mentioned that they premake their signature drinks the day of. I was disappointed and shocked to find this out since this is a fine dining restaurant! She immediately had my cocktail remade to and original cosmopolitan. For my second drink I had a wonderful glass of wine. Rein brought me samples to ensure I would pick the right red wine. Service was great. The ambiance is nothing to brag about but it is nice.
8. Cafe de Marco
Overall Ratings
4 based on 823 reviews
Tucked away in the northern most point of Old Marco is Cafe de Marco. An intimate bistro/cafe serving the most diverse selection of fresh seafood & other continental specialties since 1983. A favorite amongst locals & seasonal return visitors to Marco Isl
Reviewed By Annette G
From the outside, you wouldn't think you were about to embark on an outstanding food experience. The exterior is low key, no bells and whistles, appears smaller than it is but definitely inviting. Step through the door and be seated to experience, in my opinion, the best Marco Island has to offer. I dined with 3 other friends and, although we have been to Marco Island in the past, we never thought to dine here. Well, better late than never! Two of us ordered the house specialty, jumbo prawns, butterflied, seasoned perfectly and broiled to perfection, one had the captain's platter and the last had the shrimp scampi. When they say jumbo prawns, they mean it! Each prawn is about a quarter pound and the butterflied beauty is as big as my hand. For dessert we all shared the café puff, a beautiful and delicious ice cream ball rolled in chocolate cookie crumbs, encased in a puff pastry shell and drizzled with a delicious sauce. And to wash all this wonderfulness down - 2 bottles of prosecco. Might I mention a big thank you to our charming and delightful waitress, Jennifer! If you haven't discovered this hidden gem yet, run-don't walk-to Café de Marco!
7. Marco Prime Steaks & Seafood
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1471 reviews
Reviewed By melanie f
Had a late flight, so walked over from the Hilton after checking in. Ate outside which was nice. Kids ordered off kids menu - sliders (which son said were 'ok' and a filet which my daughter said was 'delicious'. My husband and I split the lobster tails and special skirt steak. It was all very good.
6. Little Bar Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1363 reviews
Located right on the water in the quaint fishing village of Goodland, Florida on Marco Island. Little Bar, a local tradition for 41 years, continues to serve consistently good seafood and steaks in a relaxed and friendly atmosphere. Varied menu. Fresh Sea
Reviewed By Chris W
Wow wow wow , great place seafood was of the hook no pun intended, the staff was great, awesome, friendly. This is a great place to go if your wanting great food and that old Florida feel. Small island big taste, so when your in Marco island or Naples it's worth the ride to goodland for a slice of seafood paradise.
5. Verdi's An American Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1064 reviews
Chef Sanjuan is constantly expanding his skills and is continuously praised by our local customers, as well as commended on social media for his talent of preparing food to perfection. In addition, our distinguished wine list will allow you to pair any me
Reviewed By Sully38
Lovely evening with wonderful food served by the fabulous Samantha. Wish it had a better outdoor space or that the inside was more inviting but still worth the visit.
4. Fin Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1465 reviews
Fin Bistro is a place where locals and vacationers alike can come to enjoy a delicious selection of freshly caught seafood. As a family-owned business, weâre proud to serve our favorite recipes to guests, cooking with our own special flair and designing b
Reviewed By WCH440
Fresh fish summarizes Fin Bistro. They do have steaks, chicken and pasta, too. But Iâm of the mind set that when Iâm in a tropical locale and seafood is fresh and abundant, the meat can wait until I head back home. The menu was relatively simple and not pages long. I was a little disappointed to find out that the chef is unable to deviate very much from the preparations as they appear on the menu. I was hoping to order a fresh fish blackened. However our server informed me that the chef has no seasoning with which to blacken. Entrees are medium size - not all that large. Most entrees are served on a bed of risotto, rice, or vegetable of sort, and do not include potatoes or vegetable. Those can be ordered as a side and are priced in the $6-$9 range. Most entrees are in the $29-$36 range. Angela did fine job serving us!
3. DaVinci's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 3482 reviews
Experience the charm of Italy without the jet lag. The Carvelli family has created a little slice of their homeland in the quaint atmosphere of Marco Island. Sophisticated taste blends into a family atmosphere where each guest will feel at home while enjo
Reviewed By ValerieO315
Heard great things about DaVinci's and they lived up to everything we heard. From the fresh homemade bread, to the unbelievably tasty entrees - everything was excellent! Our server Nelly was very attentive and provided great service. I had the Tagliatelle Carbonara with chicken and my husband had the Veal Porcini, both were very flavorful. The portion sizes were more than adequate - enough to bring home leftovers. We were too full to have dessert, but I bet that would have been amazing as well! It's a big place, but very busy, so if you are going in season or need to get in and out by a certain time, I would suggest getting a reservation. Highly, highly recommend!!!
2. The Oyster Society
Overall Ratings
4 based on 662 reviews
Reviewed By RockeRoanoke
We came here shortly after our arrival in Marco. We thoroughly enjoyed the Oyster Trio, Ahi Poke, Tuna Bites with spicy aioli and the Corn Flakes Grouper. All were presented beautifully and tasted wonderful. Pablo made the evening exceptional. He provided us with helpful info about the selections, timed the delivery of our orders perfectly and made the evening fun. He topped off the evening by making a paper rose for my wife. We will come back and bring friends. Hello RockeRoanoke,Thank you for taking the time to review our establishment.Our team appreciates all your great comments and we are glad to hear that Pablo made your evening fun.It will be a great pleasure to see you again at The Oyster Society!
1. Fin Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1465 reviews
Fin Bistro is a place where locals and vacationers alike can come to enjoy a delicious selection of freshly caught seafood. As a family-owned business, weâre proud to serve our favorite recipes to guests, cooking with our own special flair and designing b
Reviewed By WCH440
Fresh fish summarizes Fin Bistro. They do have steaks, chicken and pasta, too. But Iâm of the mind set that when Iâm in a tropical locale and seafood is fresh and abundant, the meat can wait until I head back home. The menu was relatively simple and not pages long. I was a little disappointed to find out that the chef is unable to deviate very much from the preparations as they appear on the menu. I was hoping to order a fresh fish blackened. However our server informed me that the chef has no seasoning with which to blacken. Entrees are medium size - not all that large. Most entrees are served on a bed of risotto, rice, or vegetable of sort, and do not include potatoes or vegetable. Those can be ordered as a side and are priced in the $6-$9 range. Most entrees are in the $29-$36 range. Angela did fine job serving us!
