Location: Lake Mary
Top Restaurants in Lake Mary
Florida, United States Food Guide: 10 Pizza food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Lake Mary
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Lake Mary. Lake Mary is a suburban city in Seminole County, Florida, United States, and is located in Central Florida. The population was 13,822 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Lake Mary
10. Pizza 1905
Overall Ratings
4 based on 52 reviews
Casual seating inside/outside, family owned Pizza Parlor, NY Pizza, Chicago Deep Dish, Grandma Pie, Stuffed Pie, and other family specialties items. We make fresh bread for our Large Sangwich selection, from roast pork to prime cold cuts. Also offering Sa
Reviewed By BDragoncop
Pizza is a very personal thing.Thin crust, thick crust, Chicago, deep dish what fits you best depends on your taste preference. Having lived the majority of my life in the Northeast and having traveled extensively I have been exposed to a variety of pizza styles. As well as homemade pizza made by Mrs. Angelicola (Sicilian mother of my childhood friend Leo. I personally am a fan of the Frank Pepe style pizza. The pizza here is the closest I've found since coming to Florida. The crust is thin and crispy without tasting like cardboard. The sauce is flavorful but doesn't drench the pizza. The cheese does not have that plastic taste like some of the national chains. Adequate toppings and an appetite stimulating aroma.The price is more than reasonable. A couple of notes, they do not sell slices on the weekend and seating is limited. Also parking can be sparse but that seems to be because of the popularity of the restaurant. Prior to their opening I would drive to Mt. Dora from Apopka to get decent pizza. 4.5 stars out of 5.
9. Grato Italian Grill and Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 33 reviews
Reviewed By AlexanderDFraser
At the time of this review, this is a new Italian restaurant/ pizzeria in Lake Mary. We were pleasantly surprised at the food. We tried everything from the Alfredo, which my son said was the best he ever had, to the spaghetti and Meatballs and even the steak..we ate every bit and are looking forward to coming back. The tap beer selection is missing an IPA. My suggestion here is to try it family style!
8. Papa Joeâs Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 54 reviews
Reviewed By zeus7218
Stumbled onto this place. food is fantastic. the Stromboli is the best I've ever had. that includes international travel. Staff is very helpful, friendly, very knowledgeable about the food they serve. I will always choose this place over most restaurants'.
7. Tomasino's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 48 reviews
Reviewed By CalArky
A friend at work recommended this on day for lunch. It was somewhat small but comfortable and busy. I ordered a Caesar salad and the Bossman Meatball Sliders. The salad was fresh and crisp and cold. The Caesar salad dressing was great. You get 3 sliders per order. The meatballs are served on Garlic Knots with marinara sauce and ricotta and mozzarella cheese blend. It was delicious and filling. Iâm going to go back and try one of their pizzas. I hear that they are great too.
6. Mellow Mushroom
Overall Ratings
4 based on 135 reviews
Reviewed By Larry G
I ordered my food and got on the interstate heading to my destination. and as we started to get ready to eat, the food was so over cooked and darn near burnt , couldn't even bite into it, we were so disappointed, we called and the girl answering said it was cause they were busy, talked with the manager he said it was because the printer went down, WHAT does that have to do with the way our food was cooked ?Larry, I am very sorry for your recent experience at the Sanford Mellow Mushroom. I would love to make it up to you, and replace your order for you. I appreciate you letting us know, and apologize for the way the situation was handled when you called the restaurant. I have placed your name on our comp log so the next time you would like some of our normally great food, just let us know and we will replace your order for you.
Most Popular Steakhouse food in Lake Mary, Florida, United States
5. Papa Joe's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By applecat79
I have only ever ordered pizza for take out here so I canât comment on the service or extended menu. However, I think this pizza is so good and a great price. My favorite is the vegetarian, hold the olives. My only complaint is they have limited topping. No hot peppers, seriously?! Oh well, itâs still delish.
Top 6 Mediterranean food in Lake Mary, Florida, United States
4. Dalli's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By WishingWest
Lunch visit with a friend. Stromboli was delicious as well as the garlic knots. Great value. Would enjoy more lunch specials but will return for sure for more Stromboli!!!!! We're so glad that you enjoyed your experience! Thank you for the review.
Most Popular American food in Lake Mary, Florida, United States
3. Chianti's Pizza & Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 236 reviews
Welcome to Chianti's Pizza & Pasta. Our focus is to bring old world recipes and flavors to Sanford! We now offer online ordering. Order your family dinner now! Chianti is a well known table wine originating from Tuscany. It was historically associated wit
Reviewed By Fulfillment16
This was our favorite local pizza place until this past weekend. I placed an online order around 4pm or so for a few pizzas. It hit around 5:15 and I was wondering why no delivery yet. I called the restaurant and the guy that picked up found the order, put me on hold for a few minutes and came back to advise that the order was never made. I asked why and he said something to the effect of somebody clicking on it and then clicking off. At this point, he said they could make the order and get it to me in 25 minutes. I asked to talk to a manager and he said he was a manager. I then asked what they could do due to the inconvenience. My money was already paid through their online portal, so I really just wanted to see how they would handle a customer service issue. He put me on hold, came back and said he talked to the kitchen manager and she said no-go. Full price for the order and if I wanted (which I had already paid), then she would provide 20% off the next order. What went through my mind? Why would I even want to place a subsequent order when they totally messed this one up, had my money and had absolutely no concern over the issue? At that point, I just told him to refund the order and weâd figure out something else for dinner. He said no problem and said he would need to âwriteâ my credit card info down to process the refund. How secure is that?? He told me that was the only method of refunding with their payment system, so I reluctantly provided it so I could get on the road and grab dinner for the family. The majority of e-commerce platforms handling payment information provide a simple refund button functionality to avoid any security issues with writing information such as this down. I am familiar with this because I have accepted payments from clients through a few different platforms. Nonetheless, I left the interaction frustrated and hungry with my money pending refund. Had I not called, weâd still be waiting on that delivery from a few days ago. Itâs a shame that the managers put in place either donât have the concern or empowerment to correct issues that they have made. No matter how much I like their pizza, I will never spend my money there again, and will be sure to share the experience whenever the opportunity arises. And tip for the owner if there is even any concern to read this - get yourself a new payment system so your folks arenât jotting down peoplesâ card info on scraps of paper sitting around your counter if they need to issue a refund. Itâs not only unprofessional, itâs incredibly risky for the customer and your business. I am absolutely embarrased by then way you treated at my restaurant.What you experienced was a dropped order.Our policy is to deliver the order immediately and provide the consumer a full refund, the system tracks by name, so as you stated, its as easy as pressing the refund/void button.I am not sure whom you spoke with, but it looks like we have some retraining to do, and I take full responsibilityfor that. I would absolutely like the opportunity to make this up to you, pleaser e mail me the date of the order and you name and contact information, and I will reach out to you.Regards,Ian [email protected]
2. Giovanni's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 194 reviews
Reviewed By 835georgeb
Every time visiting friends in Lake Mary we make it a certainty to dine at Giovanniâs! Great locally owned and operated Italian cuisine. Ask for Tim, best waiter at Giovanna! GO, ENJOYâ¼ï¸
Where to eat Italian food in Lake Mary: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Terramia Brick Oven Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 254 reviews
Reviewed By vtsand
The food here is delicious. Had the Rigatoni w/Bolognese sauce and it was divine; I couldn't stop eating it! My daughter had the Chicken Parm and declared, without even having a bite of mine, that hers was the best meal. The staff was incredibly friendly and knew many of the customers. The atmosphere is very upbeat and lively!
Where to eat Bar food in Lake Mary: The Best Restaurants and Bars
