Top Restaurants in Put in Bay
Best American food near Put in Bay, Ohio, United States
Reviews on American food in Put in Bay, Ohio, United States including The Forge, Reel Bar, Topsy Turvey's, Pasquales Cafe, Mossbacks, The Keys, Upper Deck Restaurant, The Boardwalk, Round House Bar, Frosty Bar Incorporated
Things to do in Put in Bay
10. Frosty Bar Incorporated
Overall Ratings
4 based on 330 reviews
Reviewed By SheilaMarieK
I came in for a quick bite before heading back to the mainland. Service was prompt and friendly. Food was quick and tasty. Music was a nice addition.Recommended
9. Round House Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 162 reviews
Reviewed By ChiefGuru
The Round House Bar is another of the many hot spots for food, beverages and entertainment on the main through fair of Put In Bay. Doing our make shift pub crawl through town one afternoon, we decided to stop in for a beverage and to listen to the music and comedy of Mike "Mad Dog" Adams. I gather that Mad Dog, the "Original Ziggy Zaggy Man" of Put In Bay, has been a regular at Round House, performing there for forty seasons. I understand that he rotates seasons between Put in Bay and Florida, based upon the weather. Mad Dog offers a continuous banter with the crowd, probably not for the sensitive ears of younger children. The afternoon we heard him he was heavy on the banter and jokes, while light on music. My preference would have been toward more singing, but the crowd was enjoying his routine. The bar service was really good. The beverages selections and pricing were also fine. We enjoyed a couple drinks and the crowd as much as Mad Dog. No issues in returning here on a future visit.
8. The Boardwalk
Overall Ratings
4 based on 442 reviews
Reviewed By Polkadot72
This place is on the water with many options to dine. You can sit on a covered patio or at a picnic table next to the water. Itâs cafeteria style and you get your food from one of the windows and choose a table. Water is available at a fountain and you can help yourself. Restrooms are on the boardwalk on your way in. Food is pricey but the scenery is amazing. One bowl of lobster bisque was $9.50. Lots of seafood options available.
7. Upper Deck Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 433 reviews
Reviewed By 2TXAngels
I like the Beyond burger in general and they did a good job of that plus some sweet potato fries. My friend and client dining with me though he should have tried it as well instead of his shrimp salad or something along those lines. Good vibe, nice place, decent service and surprisingly good food. It was worth the quick flight over to have lunch!
6. The Keys
Overall Ratings
4 based on 354 reviews
Reviewed By Andrea60
Stopped here for a quick lunch. We were seated immediately. The waitress was friendly and the service was quick. I ordered fish sandwiches, which were wonderful. Mine was a PoBoy where the fish was deep fried. My husband got the fish Ruben where the fish was steamed. The drinks were good but light on the alcohol. Would return.
5. Mossbacks
Overall Ratings
4 based on 249 reviews
Reviewed By Thomas R
Had dinner here, ordered the perch sandwich, which was excellent. All the food was really good. Only objection was the waitress didn't bring me my drink I ordered. Food, however, was really good.Hi THOMAS R, we are so glad that you enjoyed your perch! We also hope that you finally got the drink you ordered after you explained to your server that that there was an error. Please come see us again soon!
4. Pasquales Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 381 reviews
Casual Island dinning at its finest! Pasquales Cafe is a family friendly restaurant with fantastic views of Put-in-Bay harbor and the historic downtown. An island tradition where visitors and locals meet to enjoy the best all American breakfasts on the is
Reviewed By mikepG8652CM
Stopped in for breakfast while docked at a nearby marina. They were crowded and we were told there would be a 10 to 15 minute wait for a table - it was really just over 5 minutes. The food was excellent as always! Service was very good throughout our visit.
3. Topsy Turvey's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 189 reviews
Reviewed By drbroundtheworld
Being from the Midwest I was craving fresh fried perch so we checked Tripadvisor immediately when we arrived on the island at lunchtime and decided on Topsy Turvey's based on the reviews. Being mid September the island wasn't too busy so there was no wait and there were open tables outside on the deck overlooking the water and the sun was shining! The server (which we were pretty sure she was the owner) was super pleasant and helpful explaining the menu options. Once we made our decision, she told us a single platter would be more than enough perch for the two of us to share for lunch and she was right! Altho a bit expensive, when split between 2 you can't beat the price for the amount of perch- 3 large fillets! The platter came with fries (battered then fried-yum!) and they were great too along side with coleslaw and a pickle. We both walked away full and happy that we had some perfectly cooked, non-greasy, tasty, fresh perch! PS: Their beer menu is pretty extensive too! Boy, did we make the right decision!
2. Reel Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 197 reviews
Quality food, drinks and entertainment in an island setting
Reviewed By 518lauriek
We decided to eat lunch here while in Put In Bay on the recommendation of others, my husband had the perch tacos which were $7.00 a piece for just a tack no fries with it no chips no pickles and they were small so 2 tacos with fries added was over $20.00. I had the ceaser salad that was $13 and that was with no chicken, if you wanted chicken it was an extra $4.00. The food was ok nothing to write a great review about, the inside of the bar was done rustic and had a small place you could buy t-shirts in the corner, I'm sure if you look at other places for lunch on the island you can find a much better place.
1. The Forge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 302 reviews
Breakfast served 8 AM- 12 PM daily. Lunch and dinner served 12 PM-10 PM daily. Serving freshly made sweet and savory crepes, sandwiches, paninis, salads, soups, sliders, flatbreads, tacos and dinner entrees, as well as specialty coffee drinks, beer, wine
Reviewed By Matt S
Stayed on the island for 5 days and ate here 3 mornings. and one night! Awesome bloody mary's to help cure the morning blues and the food is awesome. You gotta go, oh and the servers are the best on the island!
