Location: Middletown
Top Restaurants in Middletown
Top Things to do in Middletown
- 1. Washington Monument State Park
- 2. Frederick Visitor Center
- 3. Big Cork Vineyards
- 4. South Mountain East Welcome Center
- 5. Distillery Lane Ciderworks
- 6. Gathland State Park
- 7. South Mountain Creamery
- 8. Historic Downtown Frederick
- 9. South Mountain West Welcome Center
- 10. Orchid Cellar Meadery and Winery
Best American food near Middletown, Maryland, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Middletown, Maryland, United States. Middletown is a suburban town in Frederick County, Maryland, United States. The population was 4,138 at the 2010 census. Located in the Middletown Valley that stretches between the Catoctin Mountains on the east and South Mountain on the west, the town reportedly gained its name from its location midway between those ranges.
Things to do in Middletown
10. Serenity Tearoom & Fine Dining
Overall Ratings
4 based on 224 reviews
Reviewed By Desea3
We were celebrating birthdays with a group of eight and were a bit disappointed there were no childrenâs menu. Our entreeâs were delicious though although each was served one at a time with more than a ten minute wait between the first and eighth meal meaning the first served was quite cold by the time everyone received their meals. We enjoyed the teas and crab dip appetizer.
9. Dutch's Daughter
Overall Ratings
4 based on 884 reviews
You come first at Dutch's and it's our mission to maintain the distinction of being your first choice in dining. Whether it's a casual luncheon, romantic dinner for two, that special dinner party, or the ultimate reception, our tradition of quality and ex
Reviewed By deniselondrie
My table had the cream of crab soup, shrimp bread, and crab cake. Generous amount of crab in the soup, shrimp bread was so yummy, and no filler in the crab cake- this place does it right. And you also get a nice chunk of bread for the table.
8. The Braddock Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 38 reviews
Historic neighborhood restaurant located minutes from Frederick, MD.
Reviewed By 751edb
The food here is consistently excellent. Homey atmosphere with knowledgable and caring owners. Step away from the cookie cutter chain restaurants run by a formula in a notebook. Enjoy thoughtful food in a relaxed atmosphere.Try the french dip sandwhich, its the best you could find.
7. Subway
Reviewed By RoccoLoveBug
The selection here is just the same as at any other Subway - sandwiches, salads, cookies. The place was clean and service was average.Parking here is very limited and because of the location sometimes poses a challenge to get back on the main road.
6. James Gang Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By Sharon K
The restaurant is located in a small strip mall right off the main town drag. It's a home town kind of place. They offer pizzas, subs, calzone, stromboli, and Italian dinners. The decor is pretty simple but the service is friendly and fast and the food is good...ideal for children or a batch of teens.
5. Schroyer's Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 25 reviews
Schroyer's Tavern is open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner and provides panoramic views of nearly every corner of the golf course. Complete with a stone fireplace, soft leather seating, full service bar, room for 175 guests and a first-class service staff
Reviewed By Errantflyer
Set in the clubhouse of a golf course, this restaurant puts out fair/good food despite poor servers and poor management of the food side of the business. Crab nachos were delivered with everything BUT crab (oops, I forgot...). Rockfish was good, muscles were sour and the smothered steak was OK. Glasses were refilled only when requested and the check was slow in coming and delivered to the Wrong Person despite explicit instructions. This could be a hit with adult supervision.
4. Fratelli's Italian and Seafood
Overall Ratings
4 based on 43 reviews
Reviewed By Kelly Y
Fratelli's has very good food and I enjoyed my meal but I felt it was a little dumbed-down, bland, American-style Italian. The portions are gi-normous! One meal is enough for 3 people - expect meals of leftovers! The service was very good - welcoming and energetic. My only complaint is that it seemed like they were mimicking Olive Garden with bland fluffy breadsticks and all-you-can- eat salad. I'd prefer a good crusty bread at a real Italian place. I would definitely return here for dessert though! Especially, I'd like to mention the cheesecake. I am a cheesecake snob. Usually I only like my own, which I inherited and have improved over the years. I grew up in NJ, eating great NYC cheesecake - the right balance of moist, somewhat fluffy but solid, sweet and tangy. That's really hard to do! And Fratelli's absolutely hits cheesecake out of the park!!!
3. Dempsey's Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 39 reviews
Reviewed By USAFret
After driving by this place for years we decided to give it a try. We were not disappointed. It is a pretty basic operation with a fairly extensive menu. Additionally, there were a number of specials. Everything we had was good and the service was friendly. If you are looking for a good basic meal this is the place.
2. JB Seafood
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Carryout Business with limited seating 20. Specializing in Fresh Seafood Raw and prepared. We also have American dishes.
Reviewed By TravelFans3
This is really located in Myersville, MD - not Middletown. First time visiting and we did carryout. The crab cakes were wonderful. Even loved their mac and cheese. The MD crab soup was good but not great. Will we go back - YES! It is a little on the pricey side but then it's good quality seafood. The inside is small with limited tables. Their menu is more than just seafood and offers a variety of items that should satisfy almost anyone. Looking forward to trying other items they offer. They normally have a large tent at the Great Frederick Fair but now you can enjoy their food anytime.
1. The Main Cup
Overall Ratings
4 based on 218 reviews
Reviewed By 197stevee
We stopped at The Main Cup for dinner the first night after our wedding, before leaving for our honeymoon. The service was great, the atmosphere was friendly and the food was delicious. We were particularly fond of the Buffalo Chicken Dip, with pita triangles. I would definitely recommend The Main Cup for a meal if you are in the area and want some just plain good American food. I will definitely go there again if I'm in the area. Safe travels!
