Top Hotels in Eleuthera
10 hotels in Eleuthera: Best hotel deals for 2023
The tranquil pink and white sands of Eleuthera beaches are the perfect remedy for any weary traveler. The Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve is an educational experience in beautiful disguise. No visit to Eleuthera is complete without a peek at the unique “glass window,” where the dark blue Atlantic bumps right up to the aquamarine Caribbean Sea. Hire a guide to show you the splendor of the island’s many mystical caves.
Restaurants in Eleuthera
1. La Bougainvillea
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 74 reviews
La Bougainvillea is a luxurious 5 star boutique hotel on 30 acres of the most beautiful beach in the world. Sit by our infinity edge pool while overlooking the crystal blue waters of the Bahamas. We are a unique place located on a rarely found secluded beach.
Just the perfect mix of peace and beauty
Reviewed By tamaz2018My favorite part of the stay was the food. This is unusual because the Bahamas is not known for food. Devin, the chef at La Bouganvillea, is a humble soft spoken man who cooks up wonders in his seaside kitchen. The lobster tacos were amazing. Oh, and don't miss trying the best burger in the Bahamas. The environment Tom created is an eclectic mix of Bahamian and Asian designs. This tasteful combination made me feel relaxed and embraced. I enjoyed immensely sitting out back listening to the ocean, feeling the gentle breeze all while being taken care of by a great staff.
2. French Leave Resort, Autograph Collection
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 236 reviews
Beautiful Resort, dock for sailboats.
Reviewed By caribnsol99Great resort. We came in on our sailboat and took a slip on their dock. Great restaurant, pool and staff. Dock manager was great, Geneva in the restaurant took great care of us. Located next to a beautiful little town. Had a wonderful time and will stop in again when in the area.
3. Villa Allamanda, Eleuthera
Overall Ratings
5 based on 197 reviews
Villa Allamanda is a charming Eleuthera Boutique Hotel featuring a modern island style decor in a garden setting with our unique breathtaking panoramic views of both sides of the island, the Atlantic Ocean & The 'Lucayan Sea'. We are located just a four (4) minute drive outside our town center of Governor's Harbour, a fifteen (15) minute stroll from our Twin Coves beach and an eight (8) minute drive from the Gov. Hbr. Airport.
Villa Allamanda Stay
Reviewed By Alisaacs04Had a wonderful time at Villa Allamanda! The Villa offers a great secluded feel while still being close enough to all the necessary amenities. Car rental also available on site? A great getaway for sure!
4. La Bougainvillea
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 74 reviews
La Bougainvillea is a luxurious 5 star boutique hotel on 30 acres of the most beautiful beach in the world. Sit by our infinity edge pool while overlooking the crystal blue waters of the Bahamas. We are a unique place located on a rarely found secluded beach.
Just the perfect mix of peace and beauty
Reviewed By tamaz2018My favorite part of the stay was the food. This is unusual because the Bahamas is not known for food. Devin, the chef at La Bouganvillea, is a humble soft spoken man who cooks up wonders in his seaside kitchen. The lobster tacos were amazing. Oh, and don't miss trying the best burger in the Bahamas. The environment Tom created is an eclectic mix of Bahamian and Asian designs. This tasteful combination made me feel relaxed and embraced. I enjoyed immensely sitting out back listening to the ocean, feeling the gentle breeze all while being taken care of by a great staff.
5. The Cove Eleuthera
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 815 reviews
The Cove, Eleuthera, is an exclusive island retreat situated on 40 lushly landscaped acres on the northern end of the Bahamian island of Eleuthera, facing the Caribbean. White sand beaches, turquoise waters, and awe-inspiring views set this pristine Caribbean hideaway apart from the rest. With daily flights from Florida, Nassau, and Atlanta, arrive at The Cove just in time for sunset. The intimate resort offers a selection of stylish seaside villas and suites, embraced by endless turquoise waters. The Cove features private white sand beaches, a fitness center, spa, open-air sunset bar and a gourmet restaurant inspired by the island's aquatic bounty. From snorkeling, paddle boarding, and kayaking to more relaxed pursuits such as lounging by the scenic, hilltop infinity pool, guests have a bevy of options at their fingertips. Additional activities include charter fishing and island excursions, scuba diving, water sports and horseback riding. Come see what makes The Cove one of the best kept secrets of The Bahamas. Paradise awaits.
Incredible Potential
Reviewed By curfewtThis property has all the makings of a truly unique and worldclass resort. But it really needs some TLC. The first room I checked into was was 2 bedroom ocean front, and it left a lot to be desired. I changed rooms to a 3 bedroom villa that was so much better (frankly I would have left if I didn't change rooms). Even though the villa was beautiful, it just has not been kept up with. A little love and focus on the details (and things working) would go a long way. The first couple days I had Chester as the villa butler, and frankly, he just wasn't great. Nearly everything I asked for was a "no" - it felt like he defaulted to saying no rather than trying to figure out solutions. He did not see details - I had to ask him to clean things up multiple times and point out obvious issues like the fridge leaking and the kitchen being dirty. BUT, everything changed when Nicole became the new butler. Hands down Nicole is the single best customer service and friendly experience I've had at a resort. She proactively saw and fixed every single detail. Even things like breakfast were 10x better with Nicole. She really gets customer service and wants to make the best experience possible for guests. I'll continue coming back and I am hopeful that things will get better with time, it seems like they are indeed aware of problems and are going to do a new renovation soon.
6. The Sunset Cove & Rainbow Room
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 225 reviews
Welcome to our little piece of paradise! The Sunset Cove and Rainbow Room is a small boutique resort with a restaurant, pool and bar located in the hearth of Eleuthera with pristine panoramic Caribbean, gorgeous nearby beach style cottages. The Resort's location on the island makes it an ideal base from which to explore the rest of Eleuthera. Within minutes of the Resort are some of the island's top tourist attractions: Surfer's Beach, the Famous Caves of Hatchet Bay, Glass Window Bridge, the Pineapple Fields of Gregory Town, plus our own Secret Beach. We even have Bonefish Graham's "Rainbow Guide" to bonefishing on Eleuthera. Our waterfront area with its seaside tennis court and some of the best snorkeling on the island (one of the sites on the Jean-Michel Cousteau Bahama Out island Snorkeling Adventures) will provide hours of enjoyment for the whole family! The vibrant and colorful The Sunset Cove and Rainbow Room and its Rainbow Bay Club is a historic property on Eleuthera Island that has seen many transformations since it was built in the 1970. Once a Restaurant with a bed and breakfast, and then a rental property, the boutique hotel now serves as one of the most casual-sophisticated small resorts on Eleuthera Island. The property features 15 uniquely decorated rooms with three different level: Deluxe, Superior and Standard for the convenience of our guest-friends, a pool and beautiful Bahamian park overlooking the Caribbean site. The restaurant at the hotel are among the best on the island and, if you’re feeling like a stroll, there is the famous Rainbow Beach just a few minutes away from the property, or you can snorkel directly from the rocks at property. Please note that our Cottages have been kept deliberately in the decoration and style of the 70s, some guests love to feel the "old Bahamas", so please book the cottages only if you really like the old feeling. If you like modern and upscale Luxury suites, we recommend you reserve one of the Luxury brand new suites 4* Hotel. For any additional question please feel free to ask.
Too Expensive
Reviewed By Roly MStaff was very friendly and helpful and they even have their own herbal rum liqueur -- Bahamaro. We selected this property because it offered kitchenettes but we got only a small fridge. One large room with Queen and single bed and old shower. Water pressure was uneven so we often had spurts from the taps. Beds were hard and pillows were lumpy. We had just come from a beachfront 2-bedroom cottage with full kitchen in South Palmetto Point that actually cost much less than Sunset, so we weren't impressed with our room. The pool and pool area are fabulous and the restaurant and bar are very nice. Had very nice Vegetarian 8-slice pizza for $28.
7. Cape Eleuthera Resort & Marina
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 80 reviews
The well-appointed modern 2 bedroom villas & 1 bedroom cottages of Cape Eleuthera provide a luxurious base for your island explorations or a comfortable place to simply relax and unwind. All villas are adjacent to the Cape Eleuthera Marina and also provide views of the Exuma Sound. Enjoy the finest interior and exterior living spaces on the island.
Amazing time
Reviewed By traceycJ3544GMNot my first Bahamas trip, favorite place so far will definitely be coming here every year. Our party of 9 stayed in two of the villas side by side, joined by family that came in on a Catamaran and docked in the marina. Staff is great, friendly and accommodating. Location is beautiful secluded area with great support from resort amenities- nice restaurant with varied menu for breakfast, lunch and dinner overlooking the Caribbean sea with gorgeous sunsets and fantastic cocktails. Sunset beach is steps from the restaurant and a great place for a leisurely ocean swim. Worth getting snorkel equipment for the week at OIO onsite or buy it at the dive shop also onsite. Everywhere you go you have coral and fish to enjoy. We rented a boat for the week and at the last minute added having a captain. SO WORTH IT. Captain Mario took care of everything and knew all of the best snorkeling, dive fishing, bottom fishing spots. Had LOTS of fresh fish each day for dinner and fished 5 out if seven days. Great times grilling out by the back verandas in the evening as the sun sets and enjoying the friendly atmosphere of the marina. Fourth hole - just down the coastline - quick 5mins in car or 20min walk -is amazing. Fantastic coral heads with so very many fish. Shallow parts and deeper parts to suit all comfort levels. Trip to the sandbar was fun, saw a giant starfish. Don’t miss Friday nights at the outside bar with the band- great fun! The Market is an unusually well stocked grocery store on the island that delivers - we had food for the week waiting in our villas when we arrived and same day delivery as we needed to fill in. Loved that the villas are equipped with washer/dryers. There were TVs in the villas, who cares, didn’t turn them on once. All in all great way to enjoy unspoiled Eleuthera.
8. Unique Village
Overall Ratings
3.5 based on 101 reviews
Everyone needs a place to lay their weary head. For travelers visiting North Palmetto Point, Unique Village is an excellent choice for rest and rejuvenation. Well-known for its quaint environment and proximity to great restaurants, Unique Village makes it easy to enjoy the best of North Palmetto Point. Guest rooms offer a flat screen TV, a refrigerator, and air conditioning, and Unique Village Hotel makes getting online easy as free wifi is available. In addition, guests can enjoy a pool and an on-site restaurant during their visit. As an added convenience, there is free parking available to guests. Travelers looking for barbeque restaurants can head to 3 J's Jerk Pit. Unique Village is sure to make your visit to North Palmetto Point one worth remembering.
Secret Treasure !!
Reviewed By Kevin246465We had been in Bahamas for 1 week and did visit Eleuthera, Nasseau, Harbour and Exuma. Unique Village was an amazing spot with well maintain and super clean rooms condition !! Amazing beach spot as this is the only hotel on this beach. We also had dinner at their restaurant, amazing fine cuisine !! We would strongly recommand for their staff, beach, rooms and nice sceanic view around the hotel at a very good deal price for bahamas ! We suggest arriving at North Eleutera airport, rent a car and visit the island. Make sure to make reservation for the car and hotel.
9. Spanish Wells Yacht Haven
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 10 reviews
The SW Yacht Haven & Resort is a boutique hotel with 6 rooms, a villa and a 30 slip marina. The facility is located on the quiet island of Spanish Wells, Eleuthera, in The Bahamas. The property also features a swimming pool, Wreckers restaurant and bar, a laundry facility and showers for marina guests.
Spanish wells is Martha’s Vineyard
Reviewed By Dianaeidem12We have Visited a few times now. And if Harbor Island is Nantucket and this is Martha’s Vineyard. Quaint charming picket fences. Ship lap with nautical restaurants overlooking the beautiful boats that come through. With travelers from all over the world in the fisherman shopping for the lobster. Golf cart by the most beautifully taken care of yards and Victorian homes that are so charming with their coastal appeal. And truly one of the most beautiful beaches in the world. A slice of paradise.
10. Daddy Joe's
Overall Ratings
5 based on 8 reviews
Went for dinner - love the atmosphere at night
Reviewed By RainEsplenhad a really good dinner with friends. Good service. I had the curried grouper. Yum. Portions were nice. Meals were served at different times, but no biggy, happens often now everywhere since covid. People are doing their best. :)
